VII INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE
ON EASTER ISLAND AND THE
PACIFIC
Visby, Sweden
August 20 - 25, 2007
Gotland University
in Collaboration with
the Easter Island Foundation
O r g a n i z e r s
Inger Österholm
Gotland University, Sweden
Paul Wallin
Gotland University, Sweden
Helene Martinsson-Wallin
Gotland University, Sweden
Christopher Stevenson
Easter Island
Foundation
K e y n o t e S p e a k e r s
Tupua Tamasese
Samoa
John Flenley
Massey University, New Zealand
"A Palynologist Looks at the
Colonization of the Pacific".
|
CONFERENCE SESSION
DESCRIPTION
& SELECTED ABSTRACTS
|
Session 1
EASTER ISLAND ARCHAEOLOGY:
CHRONOLOGY, ARCHITECTURE AND AGRICULTURE
Chris Stevenson
(Virginia Department of Historic Resources,
Richmond, Virginia, USA)
Sonia Haoa
(Rapa Nui)
Session Abstract
Several recent and widely read papers have
challenged conventional notions about the early
settlement of Rapa Nui, the tempo of cultural
elaboration as expressed through architecture,
and when the fragmentation of Rapa Nui society
occurred. In addition, there have been new
contributions that highlight the importance of
prehistoric agricultural intensification on the
organization of Rapa Nui society. Recent
excavations and a renewed emphasis on landscape
survey are providing new information on all of
these critical issues. In this session the
solicited papers will address subject matter
that can help clarify the key events and
processes that helped shaped Rapa Nui society.
top
The Natural Structure of the Volcanic Rocks on
Easter Island and their Influence on the Rapanui
Culture and Architecture: The Characteristics of
Different Quarries
Sonia Haoa Cardinali
(Centro Estudios Hanga Roa, Easter Island,
Chile)
O. González-Ferrán
(Centro Estudios Volcanologicos, Santiago, Chile
Universidad de Chile, FAU, Depto. Geografía
and Instituto Estudios Isla de Pascua)
R. Mazzuoli
(Universita di Pisa, Dipto. di Scienze della
Terra, Pisa, Italia)
We
have analysed the archaeological sites,
buildings, megalithic monuments, tools,
agricultures terraces, and manavai developed
during Rapa Nui prehistory and correlated them
with the volcanic structures and rocks which
have been identify on the geological-volcanic
map of the island. These rock forms include
materials such as hyaloclasthic palagonite tuff,
lava tunnels, tumuliform lava flows, columnar
basaltic flows, trachyte lava domes, mugearite
massive flow, and aglomero lapille tuff. We
present the location maps for the quarries, the
rock compositions, and evidence of the different
techniques used by ancient Rapanui for the
extraction of rock.
top
Ahu Motu Toremo Hiva (Poike Peninsula, Easter
Island):
Dynamic Architecture of a Series of Ahu
Nicolas Cauwe & Dirk Huyge
(Belgium Royal Art Museum, Brussels)
with the collaboration of:
Morgan de Dapper, Johnny de Meulemeester,
Dominique Coupé,
Alexandra de Poorter, Serge Lemaitre, & Wouter
Claes
(Royal Museums of Art and History, Brussels)
The
work undertaken at Ahu Motu Toremo Hiva (Poike
Peninsula, Easter Island) in 2004 and 2005 has
brought to light several unexpected elements:
the sequential emplacement of ritual platforms,
testifying to the use of a site that has at
least three times been completely rearranged
since its initial occupation in the late
13th-14th century AD, the systematic
disassembling of pebble pavements before each
phase of abandonment, and the very recycling of
one statue. All of these discoveries shed new
light on the history of Easter Island ritual
platform construction. Recycling, disassembling,
and re-use of architectural elements and statues
characterize the monuments at Ahu Motu Toremo
Hiva. In addition, the geomorphological study of
Ahu Motu Toremo Hiva has permitted us to
determine that each ahu abandonment phase
was coupled with agricultural exploitation.
Evidently, the traditional settlement pattern of
villages inserted between the ritual platform
and the agricultural land, all functioning
simultaneously, must be questioned, at least in
part. Finally, the skeleton of a male adult
buried at the beginning of the 20th century was
also found at the site. This deceased person may
well have been one of the first lepers on the
island.
top
New Calibrations for the Obsidian Hydration
Dating
of Rapa Nui Archaeological Contexts:
Implications for Initial Settlement
Christopher M. Stevenson
(Virginia Department of Historic Resources,
Richmond, Virginia, USA)
Obsidian hydration dating has been applied on
Rapa Nui since the 1960s and has served as a
supplemental method to radiocarbon dating for
many decades. The ability to directly date
obsidian tools and to establish site
occupational ranges with a large number of
samples are two analytical advantages. The
technique has been criticized because of the
non-convergence in ages with radiocarbon dating.
Several reasons for this non-convergence are
discussed and new infrared calibrations for
estimating hydration rim thickness and water
diffusion coefficients are presented. These
calibrations are applied to a large body of
previously reported hydration analyses and the
time depth of the samples is discussed.
top
Archaeology and Ancient Aesthetics: Mapping the
Sculptural Imagination of Rapa Nui
Jo Anne Van Tilburg
(Rock Art Archive, Cotsen Institute of
Archaeology, UCLA)
Cristián Arévalo Pakarati
(Mana Gallery/Galería Mana, Hanga Roa, Rapa Nui)
Dynamic geographic data sets are essential to
describing and interpreting the interaction of
natural and human phenomena on the Rapa Nui
cultural landscape. The Easter Island Statue
Project data set is drawn from mapping the
density distribution of two discrete artifact
classes (petroglyphs and sculpture) as they are
related to three classes of production and
display sites (quarries, ceremonial centers and
roads) and associated with regional
socio-political identity. Experimental
replication drawn from aspects of our data set
has produced an ecologically predictive model
that quantifies the environmental impact of
these aesthetic artifacts as products of
individual or communal activity, socio-political
demand and the objectification of religious
belief. This paper describes the concentration
of statues in Rano Raraku quarry and on one
branch of the statue transport road network, and
examines statue presence as one byproduct of
habitual production, use, discard and reuse
behaviors in specific locales not directly tied
to socio-political boundaries, status
restrictions or resource display demands.
top
Lithic Analysis for a Rapanui Rockshelter
William S. Ayres, Maureece Levin, & Katherine
Seikel
(Department of Anthropology, University of
Oregon)
A
rock shelter on the north coast of Rapa Nui
(Easter Island), used for at least 800 years,
produced a lithic assemblage that provides
evidence derived from obsidian tool and debitage
flake-type and aggregate analyses that is useful
for interpreting aspects of early Rapa Nui
technology, including resource access,
production methods, and distributional patterns.
Site activities include using obsidian flakes
for processing primarily hard contact materials,
and this interpretation is considered in light
of formal tool types, individual flake
implements, and a larger sample of worked edges.
Observed temporal shifts in technology are
limited in this collection, a continuing problem
for interpreting Rapa Nui's archaeological
record in general, but suggest that a stable
lithic technology based on obsidian and basalt
had emerged already on the island by the end of
the first millennium AD.
top
A Contribution to Archaeochronology: Discussion
of the Rapanui Culture from the Recent Research
on Natural Hazards
O. González-Ferrán
(Centro Estudios Volcanologicos, Santiago,
Chile; and
Universidad de Chile, FAU, Depto. Geografia
and Instituto Isla de Pascua)
Sonia Haoa
(Centro Estudios Hanga Roa, Easter Island,
Chile)
E. Zarate
(Universidad de Chile, FAU, Depto. Geografia
and Instituto Isla de Pascua)
Easter Island is one of the most isolated small
outcroppings of land on the Earth , but it is
not free from the effects of global geological
processes and the geophysic of natural events
such as volcanic eruptions and tsunami generated
earthquakes that have occurred many times from
the Pleistocene to recent times. A Polynesian
group arrived to Easter Island during the last
millennium and developed the Rapanui culture
represented by the archaeological record that we
see today. The island cultural chronology has
been discussed by many archaeologists who base
their interpretations mainly on stratigraphic
excavation and radiocarbon dated contexts. We
present our contribution to improve the
chronological sequence by considering the impact
of natural geophysical hazards on the Rapanui
culture. In our resent geological survey in the
island, we recognised evidence of the three
important tsunami dated to 1960, 1575, and 1200
(?), which have been imprinted on the geological
deposits and the destruction of megalithic
monuments along the southeast coast of the
island. The impacts of these events permit us to
identify and estimate the construction dates of
those monuments. As this research demonstrates,
we need to pay more attention to the natural
events in the interpretation of cultural
chronologies.
top
The Moai: A New Point of View about the
Transportation, Distribution, and Location
of the Giant Megalithic Sculptures
from
the Rano Raraku Quarry
Toward the Easter Island Coasts
O. González-Ferrán
(Centro Estudios Volcanologicos, Santiago,
Chile; and
Universidad de Chile, FAU, Depto. Geografia
and Instituto Isla de Pascua)
Sonia Haoa
(Universidad de Chile, FAU, Depto. Geografía and
Instituto Estudios, Isla de Pascua)
E. Zarate
(Centro Estudios Hanga Roa, Easter Island,
Chile)
R. Mazzuoli
(Universita di Pisa, Dipto. di Scienze della
Terra, Pisa, Italia)
The
moai are the most emblematic megalithic
monuments in the Easter Island. For many decades
archaeologists have formulated many hypothesis
about the different types of moai,
transportation methods, route locations, and
distribution between clans. Now, we present our
contribution to this discussion, from a
different point of view; one based on results of
the geological and geophysical survey in the
island. More than 95% of the moai were
carved from the hyaloclastite palagonite
volcanic tuff found at the Rano Raraku quarry.
However, the morphology the surface volcanic
rocks, their topographic location and size, plus
the shape and weight of the giant moai,
suggest that it was improbable that long
distance transport in excess of 15 km occurred
across rugged volcanic fields without damage to
the sculpture. We propose that coastal ramps
located not too distant from the quarry played
an important role in the transport process. We
propose in this paper that the main means of
transport was maritime, and one of the strong
reasons that accounts for the fact that more
than 90% the ahu.with moai were
built along the coast of the island.
top
The Easter Island Cultural Collapse
Charles M. Love
(Western Wyoming College,
USA)
Archaeological evidence for how the hypothesized
prehistoric cultural collapse of Easter Island
society came about has been virtually
non-existent, but rather extensively assumed by
much of the scientific community, and mostly by
the press. The cultural and ecological collapse
of Rapa Nui culture originates from a scenario
first presented by Mulloy (1976). The ecological
demise of the island presented by Mulloy,
especially its deforestation, has since been
well documented. But how did the ahu
building, moai moving and erection, and
the classic culture come to a halt? How did it
"decline" into the small scale warfare and
cannibalism found by European explorers? This
paper details archaeological data that points to
the process of the cultural transformation from
a society that appears to have been once
somewhat unified, into one that seems entirely
and internally antagonistic.
top
Terrestrial Laser Scanning and Geophysical
Prospection of Selected Ahu and Moai
– The First Field Season of the German
Archaeological Mission to Rapa Nui in 2007
Burkhard Vogt
(German Archaeological Institute, Commission for
the
Archaeology of Extra-European Cultures)
Thomas Kersten
(HafenCity University Hamburg, Department
Geomatics)
Maren Lindstaedt
(HafenCity University Hamburg, Department
Geomatics)
Jörg Fassbinder
(Bavarian State Department for Monuments &
Sites, Munich)
Johannes Moser
(German Archaeological Institute, Commission for
the
Archaeology of Extra-European Cultures)
The
Department Geomatics of the Hafen City
University, Hamburg, conducted non-contact 3D
documentation of ahu and moai
(e.g., Ko te Riku, Akivi, Hanga Te'e) by high-precision terrestrial laser scanning and photogrammetry, that included GPS measurements
for the later transformation of the laser
scanning and magnetic prospecting data into the
local coordinate system (SIRGAS). This first of
five documentations of the architectural remains
by repeated scanning over consecutive field
seasons will help to determine an average
erosion rate per annum as it affects the surface
of the volcanic tuff sculptures. Geophysical
survey methods were also conducted in the
immediate vicinity of the monuments, which was
originally an integrated part of the ritual
complexes. The preliminary image processing of
the data revealed excellent results. Unknown and
unseen archaeological structures beneath the
ground are clearly visible in the grey shade
plots of the magnetic image. Some of these
anomalies may be explained by earlier
archaeological test trenches (i.e., excavations
by W. Mulloy at Ahu Akivi); others point clearly
to archaeological features such as pits and
ditches previously undetected during excavation
or simply as yet unstudied (e.g., Ahu Hanga Te'e).
Altogether the results show that we are able to
trace archaeological structures beneath the
ground with high resolution and in a relatively
short amount of time.
top
Session 2
WEST POLYNESIAN PREHISTORY AND THE RISE OF THE
MARITIME CHIEFDOMS
Atholl Anderson
(The Australian National University, Canberra,
Australia)
Geoffrey Clark
(The Australian National University, Canberra,
Australia)
Session Abstract
West
Polynesia, along with the islands of Fiji,
comprise a fertile part of Oceania in which to
investigate human migration, mobility,
interaction and the development of complex
maritime chiefdoms in the last 3,000 years. This
is because the three archipelagos are relatively
close to each other and canoes were able to
travel regularly between different island
groups, unlike most other parts of Polynesia.
The prehistory of Fiji-West Polynesia displays
great diversity even though the first
inhabitants were all Lapita people and there was
ongoing interaction among island groups. This
session examines the similarities and
differences in the archaeological records of
Tonga and Samoa, including the development of
maritime chiefdoms, and considers comparative
examples of migration and social complexity in
other insular environments.
top
Seafaring and the Initial Dispersal
of Domestic Animals in Remote Oceania
Atholl Anderson
(Australian National University)
The
dispersal of domestic animals (pig, dog, chicken.
and also commensal rats), is a source of
evidence about the nature of human colonization,
including, potentially, the relative success of
voyaging. It has been used in support of the
transported landscapes model of Oceanic economic
adaptation and in suggesting, by
presence / absence of taxa, the probable
connections between archipelagos. Here, I review
the current patterns of dispersal in relation to
introduction biology and discuss them in
relation to several hypotheses that might
account for them.
top
The Tell-Tale Adze: Connecting Samoan Basalt
Adzes
to the Investigation of Political Complexity
E. Quent Winterhoff
(University of Oregon)
Stone
adzes are integral to investigating cultural
changes within Polynesian societies due to their
archaeological durability and the vital roles
they held in subsistence practices. This paper
delves into how adze studies can offer insights
into larger socio-political changes by examining
adze production and distribution during the
Traditional Period in prehistoric Samoa. During
this period, there was a marked increase in the
quantity of adze production recorded on Tutuila
Island, and a geographic expansion in the
distribution of these adzes into the larger
Fiji-West Polynesian region. As these
transformations manifested themselves together
in a certain period of time, crucial questions
need to be raised; 1) how do we quantify these
increases, and 2) what mechanisms, cultural or
otherwise, were responsible. I propose that
these increases are interrelated and a result of
coeval expansion in political control exercised
over production labor for wealth accumulation at
the expense of kin relationships.
top
The Expansion of the Tongan Maritime Chiefdom
Geoffrey Clark
(Australian National University)
The
influence of the Tongan maritime chiefdom in the
late prehistoric era moved well beyond Tonga to
incorporate not only the outer islands of the
archipelago, but other parts of the Central
Pacific including Fiji, Samoa, Rotuma and 'Uvea.
This expansion, unique to Polynesia where the
ability to project sea power was generally
confined to a single island or archipelago, was
achieved through trade, intermarriage, raiding,
warfare and colonization. We are using
traditional history, geophysics, and archaeology
to examine the development of this complex
Polynesian chiefdom, and its impact on other
islands through a study of the chiefly centre of Mua in Tonga, and excavation of Tongan sites in
eastern Fiji. The history of the sacred Tui
Tonga title, which is embodied in the monumental
architecture at Mua — fortifications, roads,
canoe facilities, and the stone-faced burial
mounds of paramount chiefs — is central to
understanding the political power of the
maritime chiefdom from 1300-1850 AD. We take a
"Centre-out" approach to determine changes
within the Tongan chiefdom, and then compare
these developments to evidence for Tongan
involvement on other islands. This suggests how
socio-political centralisation affects maritime
trade and exchange, craft specialization and
colony emplacement.
top
Archaeological Investigation of a Stone Platform
at the Malaefono Plantation, Upolu, Samoa
Helene Martinsson-Wallin
(Gotland University)
Joakim Wehlin
(Gotland University)
During field work in 2005 our attention was
drawn to an interesting prehistoric remain at
the Malaefono organic plantation close to
Saliemoa village on 'Upolu. The plantation area
had previously housed habitations since several
stone platforms / stone heaps and remains are
reported removed due to farming activities
during the last century. During 2006 we carried
out archaeological investigations in a remaining
stone platform in the area. This "star / cog"
shaped platform, with eight protrusions was
mapped and test excavated. The investigations
showed its internal structure and its relation
to other features and the surrounding landscape.
The excavation also gave indications of
settlement activities prior to the construction
of the platform at this site. This paper
presents the results of the investigation and
discusses the star mound concept.
top
The Fale o le Fe'e Project; Archaeology,
Cultural
Heritage Management, and Oral
Traditions
Helene Martinsson-Wallin
(Gotland University)
Unasa Va'a
(The National University of Samoa)
Gustaf Svedjemo
(Gotland University)
Steven Percvial
(Tiapapata Artcentre)
The
prehistoric unique site called Fale o le fe'e
(the "House of the Octopus") situated in the
village of Magiagi located inland just south of
Apia was already visited and described by
missionaries at contact phase. The structure
with its 60 stone pillars and stone lintel
overlay in the form of a traditional fale
(Samoan house) has been described as a mini
"Stonehenge". The site has subsequently been
mapped and oral tradition tied to the monument
was reported by Buck and Freeman in the
1930s-40s. During the last century (especially
the last 50 years) the site has deteriorated and
pillars have been destroyed or fallen, a decay
probably both caused by natural and human
activities. In 2006 the site was visited within
the frame work of the new archaeological program
at NUS (National University of Samoa) with the
intention to start out an archaeological project
including excavation, restoration and collection
of the oral tradition and ethnographical
evidences. This paper presents the objectives
and current results of this project. Issues
concerning possibilities and problematics of
archaeological research in Samoa, on a general
basis are also touched upon.
top
Tooth Morphology of Pacific Rat (Rattus
exulans)
Shows Clear Patterns of Human Dispersal
in ISEA and Oceania.
Keith Dobney, Masakatsu Fujita,
& Una Strand-Vidarsdottir
(University of Durham)
Human
dispersal into Near and Remote Oceania during
was perhaps the greatest diaspora ever
undertaken by humankind. Evidence for this has
traditionally been inferred from associated
material culture, language, and (more recently)
by human genetics. Recently, however, new and
important evidence for human migration in this
region is being revealed by the study of wild,
domestic, and commensal animals, deliberately or
inadvertently dispersed by people, sometimes
over great distances. Of these, perhaps the most
notable have been recent studies of the mtDNA of
ancient and modern Pacific rats and pigs, both
of which have suggested a much greater
complexity of human Holocene migration than is
encompassed by current models. A technique newly
applied within the field of zooarchaeology — outline analysis of molar teeth
— has recently
been used to begin to explore the origins and
human mediated dispersal trajectories of these
key commensal and domestic animals. In this
paper, geometric morphometric techniques applied
to Pacific rat (Rattus exulans) mandibular 1st
molars (M1) from mainland S.E Asia to Eastern
Polynesia, clearly reveal detailed and
meaningful patterning in the distribution of
dental morphotypes which must be linked to past
dispersal events. They reveal clear "Lapita" and
"Polynesian" signatures, specific dispersal
trajectories, as well as evidence of multiple
introductions to e.g., New Guinea, Hawai'i and
even Easter Island.
top
The Lapita Settlement of Samoa: Is a Continuous
Occupation Model Appropriate?
David J. Addison
(American Samoa Community College)
Tim Rieth
(University of Hawai'i)
Alex E. Morrison
(University of Hawai'i)
The
conventional model for the colonization of Samoa
postulates initially colonization during the
Lapita expansion ~2800 cal BP and continuous
human occupation of the archipelago
subsequently. We apply chronometric hygiene
protocols to the pre-2000 cal BP dates for Samoa
and find that there is a hiatus in the period
~2700-2400 cal BP. We argue that genetic and
ceramic evidence support a discontinuous
settlement model. Falsifiable expectations are
derived from our alternative settlement model,
and a field testing strategy is proposed.
top
Session 3
EASTER ISLAND ANTHROPOLOGY AND TRADITIONAL
HISTORY
Grant McCall
(University of New South Wales, Sydney,
Australia)
Rapanui is one of the best known of the Pacific
Island places, but its fame is for its natural
setting (as a disaster zone), for its most
remote island in the world status, and for its
archaeological works. Many people may be
forgiven for not knowing that there is a lively,
contemporary population on Rapanui. The purpose
of this panel is to explore aspects of Rapanui
culture and society today and in the recent
past, as well as to consider influences from the
island's traditional history. Topics such as the
anthropology and sociology of contemporary rapanui, contact history, Rapanui (i.e., "tiki")
imagery in the world at large and the use of
Rapanui as an image in contemporary debates are
amongst the areas that would be most welcome.
Prospective participants are encouraged to
propose other themes and topics in the
anthropology and traditional history of the
"island at the end of the world", as one
translation of Te Pito ote Henua has it.
top
When Home is the Navel of the World.
Life Experiences and Expressions of Young Rapa
Nui
Olaug Irene Rosvik Andreassen
I
describe aspects of being young in a
geographically isolated yet world-known place
like Rapa Nui. More specifically, I explore how
life experiences of a group young adult Rapa Nui
can be coloured by spatiotemporal circumstances,
while their practices within these structures
can in turn influence what Rapa Nui becomes. The
outcomes of this exploration will be tentatively
analysed and compared to personal experiences,
following the guide lines of Pierre Bourdieu's
"participant objectivation" (Bourdieu 2003) and
Lefevre's concept of "Third Space".
top
Why Are We Living in the Past?
Rapa Nui Research Perspectives
Patrick M. Chapman & Maria Eugenia Santa Coloma
While
archaeologists inherently focus on the past,
linguistic, biological and cultural
anthropologists can study either the past or
present. Few of the so-called "mysteries" or
"enigmas" of Rapa Nui remained unanswered. While
there is continuing research on the rongorongo
tablets, what caused the population decline and
how the moai were moved, we now have a
good idea of where the people came from, how the
moai were constructed and what they
represent. However, there is a noticeable lack
of anthropological information regarding the
modern Rapanui population, including their
beliefs, economics, social stratification,
impact of immigration, and population gene flow,
cultural change, health and well-being. These
and many other issues are prominent in the
anthropological research of other Pacific
islands but are almost absent for Rapa Nui. In
this paper we examine past trends in the last
fifteen years of research concerning Rapa Nui
and suggest some ideas for future investigation.
top
The Mythical Appear of the Moai:
Easter Island and Popular and Material Culture
Ian Conrich
Studies of Easter Island have predominantly
sought to understand its archaeology through
historical analysis. How the moai were
created, constructed, and seen have been the
subjects of research that has approached the
stone figures within the island landscape. Yet,
the moai have long held a popular appeal
that has extended far into the cultural arenas
of Western societies that have been drawn to
fantasies of a detached and distant civilisation.
Murder mysteries, alien visitors, time travel,
and hidden treasure have been a part of the
island through popular fictions that have
depicted professors and archaeologists as both
villains and heroes. Popular narratives have
seen the island explored variously by "Indiana
Jones", "Dr Who", and "Scooby Doo", with ancient
tablets able to resurrect the moai, and
the stone figures given the power to talk and
walk. In this paper, I seek to understand the
popular appeal of Easter Island and the moai
in particular. Fiction films, cartoons, computer
games, novels, and Marvel comic books will be
central to this study. As will objects of
material culture, which position miniature
replicas of the moai as tissue box
holders, glowing lamps, salt and pepper shakers,
pieces in a board game, fruit machine symbols,
and garden ornaments. It will be argued that the
mythical appeal of the moai within
popular and material culture reveals a number of
factors: the myth of creation, the myth of
movement, the myth of power, and the myth of
presence.
top
Rapa Nui Identity: The Long-Term Perspective
from a Rapa Nui Point of View
Viki Haoa
As a
personal Rapa Nui comment to the research
project of Helene Martinsson-Wallin this paper
will discuss questions concerning the possible
existence of a collective "Rapa Nui identity",
from the mythical past to the present. The
questions range from speculative ideas such as
whether even the first Polynesians settlers
might have imagined the island as a unique place
or what it can be that makes Rapa Nui so special
in the eyes of both inhabitants and outsiders,
to the contemporary problems of how to balance
tourism with heritage management and locally
lived experiences with global scientific
expertise.
top
Easter Island in the Comics: 65 Years of
an Island's Career in the American Imagination
Beverly Haun
During research for a book focusing on the
cultural impact of eighteenth century Pacific
explorer texts that featured "Easter Island",
one source I used for investigating the
re-circulation of such books and images was
eBay. Frequently my quest produced graphic texts
of another kind, American comic books from 1940
to the present featuring moai, usually in
situ on a wildly fantastical version of the
island. Over the course of three years, through
eBay and other web-based comic book
re-circulation sites, I put together what is
possibly the largest collection of English
language "Easter Island" comics, 46 in all. This
collection is now forming an important part of a
project to examine the way moai and Rapa
Nui have been taken up, mediated, presented, and
received within American popular culture. My
starting point is to identify what categories
these comic images and narratives sort
themselves into. With this in mind, I propose a
slide show (Powerpoint), offering examples by
category in order to deal with a number of key
questions. What identities of Rapa Nui, the
Rapanui and their moai are imagined by
"the world at large" in such an "undisciplined"
medium. How do these imagined identities mediate
perceptions in this context? What kinds of
cultural spaces are created by such imaginings?
What is lost?
top
An Exhibition as a Tool to Express Identity:
The He a'amu Tupuna, He Mana'u a Mu'a Project
Maria Eugenia Santa Coloma
History has made an impression on all societies
and cultures to varying extents, based on
multiple factors. This is the case with museums,
which are no longer a mere exhibition of
artifacts dominated by aesthetic functions, but
places of gathering where the local population
can express cultural identity in different ways.
A case study is the exhibit "He a'amu tupuna, he
mana'u a mu'a", prepared for the Father
Sebastian Englert Anthropological Museum of Rapa
Nui. The exhibit aims to rescue the tales of the
past through the voices of the elders, providing
Rapanui a place to revive their traditions and
to tell their own history in first person so
that those tales last in time, enabling them to
reach the young generation of the island. Set in
five separate elements following a chronological
order, the exhibit "He a'amu tupuna, he mana'u a
mu'a" targets diverse goals such as the
preservation of the Rapanui culture and the
reinforcement of their identity as an indigenous
group. The display allows for this identity to
be expressed in different ways. Their history is
told by the Rapanui themselves rather than by
the writings bequeathed by the Europeans
visitors to the island throughout many decades.
Thus, the value of the exhibition rests more
within the collective memory than in the
heritage worth of the artifacts exposed, making
of the museum a place of memory, a space where
part of the own Rapanui identity is disclosed
and where the singularities and richness of the
cultural heritage of their people are in
display.
top
The Heyerdahl Heritage
Donald P. Ryan
The
year 2007 marks two anniversaries: It has been
five years since controversial Pacific scholar
Thor Heyerdahl passed away, and 60 years since
his provocative Kon-Tiki expedition successfully
crossed the Pacific from South America to
Polynesia. Much has happened during the
intervals of both occasions and this paper will
address, elucidate and update several aspects of
Heyerdahl's perspective and legacy.
top
Lost and found: Tracking the Orongo "Doorpost".
Jo Anne Van Tilburg
On
June 2, 1914, Rapanui consultants working with
Katherine Routledge of the Mana Expedition to
Easter Island excavated from Orongo a basalt
paenga adorned with a carved anthropomorphic
face. Considered to be one of the expedition's
prized objects, it was crated and stored at Mataveri for eventual removal from the island,
and then disappeared. A long search for this
important carving among museum and private
collections was futile until 2006. This paper
details the original discovery of the Orongo "doorpost", its archaeological history and
ethnographic context, and tracks its path
through the 1914 "native rising" into a private
collection and thence into the Easter Island
Statue Project archive. The role of the Orongo "doorpost" in comparative iconography, as well
as in Rapanui entrepreneurship and political
expression of the time, is examined.
top
1000 Years of Easter Island Settlement
Patricia Vargas & Claudio Cristino
During the last 285 years the community and
territory of Rapa Nui have experienced dramatic
sociopolitical, economic and structural changes.
A complex and irreversible process of
acculturation continues today. This paper
discusses changes that are transforming the
scientific research and the cultural patrimony
into a "commodity" and are modifying the
directions of current and future scientific work
on the island, heightening their role in
processes of construction of cultural identity.
Conflicts between organizations, individuals and
groups of interest are strongly focusing in the
archaeology, which is increasingly seen as a
unique source of monetary resources, power and
influence. Researchers, developers or political
agents and a growing number of visitors roam the
island. More than ever before, these join an
increasing number of islanders who raise their
personal or instrumental views of the past and
project them in the community to influence the
present and to design the future. The oral
traditions, the archaeological data, and
historic documents are scrutinized and
interpreted time and time again to sustain
external or internal sociopolitical or economic
aims. We put under discussion the idea that is
required of the scientists to examine the
implications of the fact that the archaeological
or historicist reconstructions of the past of
Rapa Nui are defied by this extraordinary
revisionism that paradoxically nourishes and is
contributing to the foundation of a "new
cultural identity".
top
The Easter Island Foundation's Scholarship
Awards.
Marla Wold
A
brief history of the scholarships funded by the
Easter Island Foundation and the Wiegand Family
Memorial Scholarship will be given. The program
began in 2002 and continues to award
scholarships to Rapanui youth studying at the
university level and in graduate school. The
program has been very successful to date and
hopes to raise additional funding for more
awards. A short personal history of each
scholarship recipient will be given. Highlights
will include the recipients' educational goals,
career choices, and how these will be
interrelated on Easter Island.
top
Being Rapanui (54-minute video)
Santi Hitorangi
The
video, in English with subtitles, explores
contemporary issues of identity and autonomy on
Rapanui, interview mainly, but not exclusively,
the Rapanui themselves, recorded on the island
itself. At once a very personal and a scholarly
documentary, narrated by the film maker and
related to his published article on the topic.
top
Session 4
EAST POLYNESIAN ARCHAEOLOGY:
RECENT ARCHAEOLOGICAL RESEARCH
AND IMPLICATIONS FOR EXPLAINING
PACIFIC PASTS
Reidar Solsvik
(The Kon-Tiki Museum, Oslo, Norway)
Ethan Cochrane
(University College London, UK)
Session Abstract
This
session highlights recent research in East
Polynesia from the marginal islands and
archipelagos of Hawai'i, Marquesas, Rapa Nui, and Aotearoa, to the central archipelagos of the
Cooks, Tuamotus, Society Islands and others.
Presenters will outline the results of recent
research and discuss broad theoretical
implications in domains such as the development
of sociopolitical complexity, interaction and
exchange, population relatedness, environmental
change, and human competition. Potential
speakers are welcome to discuss these themes and
others with the session organisers.
top
The East-West Polynesia Boundary:
An Archaeologically Useful Concept?
David Addison
Nearly 70 years ago Edwin Burrows delineated a
cultural boundary between East and West
Polynesia. This paper reviews archaeological,
oral-historical, and linguistic evidence for
contact across this border and explores the
archaeological utility of conceptualizing a
boundary between East and West.
top
Time and Temples: Chronology of Marae
Structures in the Society Islands
Reidar Solsvik
(Institute for Pacific Archaeology and Culture
History,
The Kon-Tiki Museum)
Paul Wallin
(Gotland University, Institute for Archaeology
and Human Osteology, and
Institute for Pacific Archaeology and Culture
History,
The Kon-Tiki Museum)
In
this paper we give an overview of the
chronological evidence from four field seasons
of excavating marae sites on Huahine, in the
Leeward group of the Society Islands. We also
briefly discuss our findings in light of earlier
work, mainly done on the islands of the Windward
group. Since the beginning of scientific
research in Polynesia it has been assumed that
the Society Islands marae complex developed
early. This may not be the case, and it is
possible that these temple sites did not play an
important part in Society Islands religious
practices or socio-political structure until
after AD 1500.
top
Phylogenetic Analyses of Polynesian
Ceremonial Architecture
Ethan Cochrane
(University College London)
The
cultural relatedness of Polynesian populations
is exhibited through similarities in ceremonial
architecture across multiple island groups.
While many archaeologists and ethnologists have
proposed specific cultural connections between
the architectural traditions of different
islands, there has been no quantitative analysis
of homologous similarities in ceremonial
architecture across Polynesia. In this paper I
present a cladistic analysis of Polynesian
ceremonial architecture from islands in West
Polynesia, the Society Islands, the Tuamotus,
Rapa Nui, and Hawai'i. Cladistics arranges
classes into a branching hierarchy based on the
distribution of derived (i.e., more recent) and
ancestral characters across those classes. The
results of the cladistic architectural analysis
document new patterns of cultural relatedness
among the islands of Polynesia.
top
Archaeological Evidence of Early East Polynesian
Ritual Structures
Reidar Solsvik
(Institute for Pacific Archaeology and Culture
History,
The Kon-Tiki Museum)
Theories of the origin and development of
Polynesian ritual
space(s) are constructed upon
comparative linguistics and comparative
ethnography, as well as archaeological data.
Consensus seems to be on a conceptual
development of ritual space in Ancestral
Polynesian Societies. The malae and
marae / ahu / heiau complexes of ethnographical
Polynesia are seen as variations of a common
theme. In this paper I present an alternative
model based upon only archaeological data. What
evidence is there for ritual activity or
religious architecture in excavations of early
sites in East Polynesia? Based upon the
archaeological evidence alone, when would we say
that the classic Polynesian ahu / marae / malae
complex developed? And, did it spread across
this area with settler voyages, or at a later
time?
top
Prehistoric Fishing in Polynesian Societies
Christelle Carlier
(Doctorat d'anthropologie, ethnologie et
préhistoire
de l'Océanie Université Paris, Panthéon-Sorbonne)
The
fishhooks represent one of the best evidence on
fishing in prehistoric Polynesian societies.
These archaeological artefacts are numerous but
rarely analysed with a global perspective: what
kind of fish is it used for? Which processes are
involved? When and where did the fishermen use
it? These questions are closely connected with
the human subsistence system developed on these
remote islands. What part did the fishing
activities represent? We attempt to answer these
questions through the study of two sites which
yielded a great number of well-preserved
fishhooks, combined with fish remains: the
Manihina dune (Ua Huka, Marquesas islands) and
Tangatatau rockshelter (Mangaia, Cook islands).
The typological study of the artefacts, the fish
bones analysis and an ethnologic study about Ua
Huka and Nuku Hiva fishing traditions can give us
information on the link between the gear and the
fishes and shed light on one part of the ancient
Polynesian fishing.
top
A Multi-level Selection Framework for Analyzing
Community Patterning on Rapa Nui:
An Example from the Northwest and South Coasts
Alex Morrison
(University of Hawai'i at Manoa)
Carl Lipo
(California State University Long Beach)
Terry Hunt
(University of Hawai'i at Manoa)
Research on Rapa Nui community patterning has
lacked a theoretical framework for understanding
the evolution of social organization and group
formation. Despite widespread recording of the
spatial distribution of surface remains across
large sections of the island, many fundamental
questions regarding the scale of community
organization remain unresolved. Recent
theoretical advances in the evolution of
organization demonstrate that multi-level
selection is an appropriate model for
distinguishing the scale of community
interactions and understanding the evolution of
"complex" social organization. However,
measuring organizational structure requires the
development of appropriate archaeological units
for linking the theoretical stipulations of the
model to the empirical record. Here we outline
the use of a multi-level selection framework
using a case study from the Northwest and South
coasts of Rapa Nui. Documenting community
organization will ultimately facilitate a better
understanding of the development of competition,
cooperation, and megalithic construction on the
island.
top
Compound Funerary Practices and Final Burial in
Ancient Marquesas as Seen from Manihina (Ua Huka)
Pascal Sellier
(CNRS, Laboratoire d'Anthropologie des
Populations du Passe,
LAPP de PACEA, UMR 5199) Pascal Murail
(Universite Bordeaux 1, LAPP de PACEA UMR 5199)
Eric Conte
(Universite de la Polynesie Francaise, Centre
International
de Recherche Archéologique sur la Polynesie,
CIRAP)
Manihina is a costal site on Ua Huka Island, in
Marquesas archipelago (French Polynesia), and
has been so far excavated during one evaluation
and three archaeological campaigns. Its main
features are a laying-out of the sand dune with
stone slabs, few paepae pavements and
many human and non-human inhumations: Around 40
burials concern human of both sexes and all
ages, and there are also 10 pigs and 2 dogs. One
of the human skeletons gave a radiocarbone date
circa mid-15th century cal. AD. An archaeo-anthropological
analysis of the burials leads to distinguish
many different funerary practices in the site:
Simple individual inhumation; use of coffin,
canoe-coffin or stone covering; re-opening of
burial for supplementary individual; body
preparation such as mummification or limited
disarticulation after partial decay; intentional
post-disposal modification including skull
taking; multi-stage burial including complete
disarticulated secondary burial. Probably
related to the status of the deceased, some of
those practices are not documented in the
previous archaeological data from the Marquesas
and many are not clearly attested in the
ethnological record from the early European
observations. The question is also the link
between those different practices because some
of them can be seen as different phases of the
same burial rite; in that view, the nature of
the "final burial" for ancient Marquesans can be
questioned.
top
Session 5
PAST INTERACTIONS WITHIN THE WESTERN PACIFIC:
THE ARCHAEOLOGICAL EVIDENCE
Christophe Sand
(New Caledonia Museum)
Session Abstract
This
session will explore the current evidence and
develop model in explaining past social and
economic interactions within the western
Pacific. Although exchange and social systems
from the ethnographic present is often used in
modelling the past, it can be shown that this
regions past is unique with the present systems
being the endpoint of thousand of years of
change. We invite papers from archaeologists
working in the western Pacific who wish to
explore this theme of identifying and modelling
the nature of past interactions in the
colonisation and subsequent development of the
western Pacific.
top
Cave and Rock Shelter Use in the Mariana
Islands, Western Micronesia: Multifacetted
Insights
into Chomorro Settlement from Rota
Steven Wickler
(Tromso University)
Archaeological excavations from a recent road
project on Rota in the Northern Marianas have
documented prehistoric activity in nine site
complexes of solution caves and rock shelters
distributed across a majority of the
physiographic zones on this island. These
results provide a unique overview of cave and
shelter use extending from second century AD
Pre-Latte occupation up until the early historic
period. Site use features include evidence of
both temporary and more intensive / permanent
occupation, artifact production, burials and
rock art. A majority of shelter activity dates
to the Latte Period with a trend towards more
extensive and intensive site use after c. 1200
AD suggesting expansion into more marginal
locations at this time. There also appears to be
a contrast in the nature of site use between
larger bedrock outcrop shelters and more
ubiquitous small boulder overhang shelters. The
collective results from Rota can be used as a
baseline for inter-island comparisons in order
to develop a general model for cave / shelter use
in the Marianas as a whole. This has relevance
for understanding patterns of interaction within
the archipelago and aspects of Latte Period
expansion in particular.
top
The Tutuila Basalt Export Industry, the
1200-1400 AD Samoan Maritime Expansion, and
Possible
Earlier Periods of Samoan Regional Influence
David J Addison
The
proto-historic Tongan Maritime Empire is well
known to Pacific archaeologists. Less well
understood is the role of Samoa as a regional
player. Since the first anthropological work in
Samoa in the 1920s, Tutuila has been known as a
center of basalt tool manufacture. The last
decade has seen a doubling of the number of
lithic sites, with several now securely dated.
This paper reviews the evidence for large-scale
basalt tool manufacturing on Tutuila and the
geographical and temporal spread of those tools
in the southwest Pacific. Linguistic, oral
historical, and archaeological evidence are
mustered to argue that Samoa was a dominant
regional influence prior to the rise of Tonga as
a regional power.
top
Diasporas and Dispersals: Colonization
and Interaction in the Western Pacific
Ian Lilley
(University of Queensland)
This
paper will consider how we might reconcile
issues of scale in our attempts to describe and
explain processes of colonization which must
have involved interaction with existing
populations. It will range models of diaspora
focused on human-scale social processes against
dispersalist scenarios that rest on large-scale
biogeographical dynamics to determine if both
can be accommodated by the empirical evidence to
hand.
top
Interactions in New Caledonia During Prehistory:
The Archaeological Data and its Significance
Christophe Sand, Jacques Bolé, & André Ouetcho
(Department of Archaeology of New Caledonia)
This
paper will present the evolutions of the
interaction-spheres developed by the traditional
communities of New Caledonia over their nearly
3000 years of pre-European chronology.
Archaeological studies have identified major
changes in the flow of material exchanged, the
direction of the exchanges and the distances
traveled by the items depending on the period
studied. In the first settlement phase related
to Lapita, a common cultural background and low
population density favoured regular interactions
between related communities. The progressive
diversification of cultural traditions over the
first millennium of settlement highlights the
appearance of distinct cultural entities over
the archipelago, with the breakdown of some
earlier interaction routes. During the first
millennium AD, the archaeological data signals a
clear isolation process between the main
islands, allowing for the rise of localized
traditions. This is followed during the second
millennium AD by a new development of
archipelago-wide interactions, in directions
unrelated to those at play 1,000 years before.
The paper will present these differences over
time and discuss their overall significance in
our modeling of Melanesian interactions.
top
Oceanic Tattooing and the Implied Lapita
Ceramic Connection
Wal Ambrose
(Australian National University)
The
ethnographic picture of the richly tattooed
Polynesians has been seen by some as an
expression of a decorative treatment inspired by
designs on Lapita pottery from more than 2,500
years ago. This view rests both on perceived
design resemblances and an implied connection
between the act of tattooing on skin and dentate
stamping on pottery. The carriage of complex
designs over such a long time span can be
doubted when no intermediate ceramic wares are
found between its early manifestation and the
purported resemblance in tattoo recorded
ethnographically. The evidence for tattoo alone
is hard to find in the archaeological record,
but what little evidence there is suggests a
more complicated story. The simple operational
parallel between decorating pottery with toothed
stamps and human skin with multi-pronged needles
can be examined in a wider context to include
the distributional range of techniques used for
tattooing within the southwest Pacific as
recorded ethnographically. The hypothesis of the
relationship between Lapita designs and tattoo
has not been convincingly tested in any study.
This paper aims to address the question of
tattooing technology and Lapita stamped
decoration.
top
New Prehistoric finds in the Manus Region —
Preliminary conclusions and Perspectives
Mads Ravn
(Aarhus University)
As a
part of the research initiative: Globalisation
in the past and the present — a Joint
Anthropological-Archaeological Research Project
in Manus Papua New Guinea, initiated by
Professor Helle Vandkilde — a team of eight
persons, archaeologists and anthropologist from
Aarhus University went to do fieldwork in the
Manus Province and its surrounding islands
Baluan, and Mbuke. After a season of fieldwork
in the Manus Region (Mbuke and Baluan) this
paper is a presentation of the results reached
so far. A number of finds among others a rare
prehistoric skeleton and its find context is
being presented. Also features from an open-area
settlement site is being presented.
top
Session 6
HUMAN IMPACT ON ENVIRONMENT AND LANDSCAPE OF
PACIFIC ISLANDS
Andreas Mieth
(University of Kiel)
Hans-Rudolf Bork
(University of Kiel)
Session Abstract
Even
though the colonisation history of many Pacific
islands merely reaches back less than one
thousand years, in some cases only a few
centuries, these islands still pose as examples
of the dramatic impact of humans on environment
and landscape. Horticulture, agriculture,
utilisation of wood, stock farming and the
import of new species have changed landscapes,
soils, vegetation and fauna tremendously during
the prehistoric times as well as after the
arrival of the Europeans. The consequences of
these degradative changes still mould and
influence the societies of many Pacific islands
up to this day and threaten also their future
existence. Historical analysis is necessary for
foresight. The contributions in this section
shall document how changes in the habitat of
Pacific islands can be spatially and
chronologically reconstructed using the
techniques and procedures of geo-archaeology,
paleo-ecology, geology, soil science, and
landscape analysis. The results of the research
presented substantially extend the knowledge of
the cultural development and ecological impact
of humans in the Pacific region.
top
Evidences of the Prehistoric Presence of
Jubaea chilensis Palm in Easter Island
Juan Grau
Since
1986, the author has held the thesis that
Jubaea chilensis was the prevailing palm
tree of prehistoric Easter Island for many
centuries. Pollen, as well as prehistoric
coconut endocarps very similar to those of
continental Jubaea have been found. Not
only these findings but further evidence are
indications that the original thesis stands
strongly. Examples of further evidence are:
Molds of palm tree trunks found in the lava of
Terevaka volcano; representations of palm trees
in the rongorongo tablets whose
characteristics are definitely coincident with
those of the typical Chilean palm tree; early
writings and logbooks of old time sailors
mention the existence of palms bearing tiny
coconuts. The author has also demonstrated the
feasibility of hydrochoric migration of seeds
from the coast of Chile to the island. Later
findings in this direction are consistent at
Poike and other sites: Molds in clayish soil,
found under big carbonized logs, correspond
morphologically and sidewise to the typical
cylindrical Jubaea roots. Studies on
phytolites and DNA of remains mentioned are
being carried out. These results will give a
final word as to the actual identity of the
prehistoric Easter Island palm tree.
top
Palm Trees on Easter Island: New Phytolith
and Radiocarbon Data
Clare Delhon & Catherine Orliac
Easter Island was formerly covered with palm
trees that constituted one of the most
distinctive attributes of the landscape. Twelve
14C dates were obtained from fragments of wood
and of nuts discovered in archaeological sites
and in cracks in cliffs. These dates, which
cover a period between AD 1210 and 1440, are
mainly centred around the 14th century which
suggests that the population of palm trees was
still important at this time. The lack of dates
after AD 1450 suggests that the palm forest
greatly decreased during the 15th century,
without disappearing completely, as is proved by
the European accounts. The existence of palm
trees on Rapa Nui is confirmed by the presence
of numerous palm phytoliths in archaeological
sediments. Phytoliths are biogenic opal
particles produced by plants. Because of their
chemical composition, they are usually well
preserved even in sediments unfavourable to the
preservation of organic remains. Palm (Arecaceae)
produce great quantities of phytoliths,
including a very characteristic "spherical
echinate" morphotype. The morphometric analysis
of that kind of phytolith made it possible to
improve our knowledge of Paschalococos disperta,
the Rapanui extinct palm. The statistical
comparison of fossil Easter Island palm
phytoliths with phytoliths extracted from
various palm species (Jubaea chilensis,
Juania
australis, Cocos nucifera, various species of
Pritchardia) showed that phytolith assemblages
produced by Jubaea chilensis are close to those
from Easter Island sediments. Nevertheless,
because of the differences between the two pools
of data, we put forward the hypothesis that more
than one species grew on the Island (Delhon &
Orliac, 2004). Moreover, phytolith morphotypes
sometimes vary from one part of the plant to
another. We investigate the differences between
trunk and leaf phytolith spectra, in order to
determine which parts of plants are involved in
archaeological deposits. In addition to
paleo-ethnobotanical implications, the
characterisation of leaves versus stem (which is
currently impossible by wood anatomy criteria)
will improve the interpretation of radiocarbon
data. Indeed, if the trunk is a long-lasting
organ that can sometimes be several centuries
old, leaves represent a shorter period, and thus
are more accurate for radiocarbon dating.
top
Microfossil Analysis of Soils at Te Niu
Demonstrates
Forest Clearance and Diverse Dryland Crop
Production Beginning in AD 1300
Joan A. Wozniak & Mark Horrocks
Plant
microfossil analysis was recently carried out on
12 soil samples associated with a variety of
landscape features at three locations (100-250 m
a.s.l.) on the northwest coast of Easter Island
at Te Niu. The results indicate burning of
palm-dominated forest and the development of a
mixed-crop, dryland production system. Charcoal
and obsidian associated with the soil samples
provide a radiocarbon and obsidian hydration
timeframe. The original Te Niu forest was
cleared probably between AD 1300 and 1450, with
coastal forest cut initially and upslope forest
a century or more later. Starch grain, pollen
and phytolith evidence indicates cultivation of
four introduced crops: common yam (Dioscorea
alata), sweet potato (Ipomoea batatas),
taro (Colocasia esculenta) and bottle
gourd (Lagenaria sicera-ria). The results
show the potential for this type of analysis in
providing direct evidence of crop type and range
elsewhere on Easter Island.
top
Easter Island: If no Collapse, What Else?
Cultural Adaptations in a Changing Environment
Jan J. Boersema & Ruben Huele
For
many scholars Easter Island (Rapa Nui) is a
textbook example for a flourishing and highly
developed culture that has collapsed as a result
of the overexploitation of natural resources.
Doubts on this "overshoot and collapse" theory
have been voiced since 2002. A collapse in the
way most authors have described it, involving
starvation, major warfare and cannibalism is
neither supported by the 18th century journals
nor by the scientific evidence. More recently
strong evidence has been presented in favour of
a relatively late arrival of the Polynesian
settlers and a major role (by preventing
regeneration) of the Polynesian rats in the
apparent deforestation. However, the stronger
the case grew against the repeated claims of a
pre-European "ecocide" the greater our longing
for a more reliable picture of the past. Hunt's
hypothetical population model is dissatisfying
in this respect and seriously flawed for the
period after the first European Contact with
Easter Island. It even is at odds with the
written text of his paper. While Hunt's model
suggests a demographic collapse following the
first visit by the Dutch in 1722, we maintain
that Easter Island has undergone an
unexceptional demographic transition. Our
improved model is based on demographic and
anthropological reasoning. Finally we will raise
the question if this "reconstructing the past"
bears any relevance to the present day debate on
sustainability and quality.
top
Perspectives on Human Management of Woody
Species
and Dynamics of Co-adaptation Between Societies
and Forests in the Pacific Islands:
A Prospective Research in Anthracology in New
Caledonia
Emilie Dotte Christophe Sand, John Ouetcho,
Jacques Bolé, & David Baret
This
paper will propose a presentation of the first
results acquired during a PhD program
associating the palaeo-ecological and
archaeological laboratories of the ANU, Paris I,
and the New Caledonia Department of Archaeology,
that try to precise the environmental dynamics
in the northern Grande Terre of New Caledonia
during kanak precontact times (i.e., mainly the
second millennium AD). It is focused on the
particular study of forest types changes
compared with the anthropogenic colonization and
lay-out of the landscape, the human management
and use of woody species. The study is based
mainly on an anthracological approach — analysis
and identification of charred woody remains
conserved in archaeological site or pedo-sedimentary
layers — but also on the examination of general
archaeological data relating to settlement
patterns and horticultural practices, with the
integration of socio-cultural data on kanak
societies. This project tries to apply for the
first time the anthracological approach in New
Caledonia, and hence to test its potential for
South West Pacific Islands palaeo-ecological and
archaeological research. A first reference
collection of woody species linked with an
identification atlas have been created, and the
way to adapt the methods and approaches of
anthracology to a South West Pacific Island
(fieldwork and research topics specificities)
are explored. The approach is based on recent
perspectives developed on the relationships
between human societies and the environment,
such as the link between the development of
horticultural, arboriculture and forest
management practices, the need to consider the
ongoing double dynamics of adaptation and
pressure between human societies and the
environment, or the timing and modes of
introduction and / or domestication of vegetal
species (mainly trees and tubers in this case).
We also emphasise the need to consider rapid
climatic changes and data on the local cultural
system of representation to build models of
human-environment interactions. We will present
here the first perspectives developed from the
work realized, and the first conclusions reached
about the limits, potentialities, and adapted
methods of anthracology in New Caledonia.
top
Prehistoric Impacts to Pacific Marine Fisheries
in Archaeological, Cultural, and Applied Context
Alex Morrison & Terry Hunt
(University of Hawai'i, Manoa)
Evidence for human induced changes in marine
ecosystems structure in prehistoric Polynesia
has recently been discussed in a number of
studies. Here we briefly review theses impacts
and outline the theoretical and methodological
issues needing consideration when investigating
evidence for resource depression using
archaeological data. Relevant issues include the
application of foraging theory models, the use
of biological life history data, and
comparability in quantification and recovery
methods. Broader patterns in Polynesian
prehistory perhaps associated with resource
sustainability are also discussed. Finally, we
examine the integration of archaeological,
historical, and modern data for applied
conservation biology and discuss the challenges
of such an application.
top
Interactions Between Man and Landscape
on the Galápagos Islands
Andreas Mieth & Hans-Rudolf Bork
Ever
since the Europeans discovered the Galápagos
Islands, the archipelago has been subject to
drastic environmental changes. Ships' crews,
settlers and domestic animals decimated the
populations of native birds and giant tortoises.
The archipelagos natural vegetation has been
almost completely damaged or destroyed by means
of lumbering, slashing and burning, agriculture
and feral domestic animals. Humans imported
highly competitive neophytes to the islands
which rapidly repressed the indigene vegetation.
Whereas such biotic changes are in the focus of
much research, the interactions between humans,
soils and topography on the Galápagos Islands
have hardly been investigated. The authors
researched on selected islands of the
archipelago how land use has changed the
topography and soils. The results of their field
studies show significant interactions between
land use, water balance and balance of matter:
In the highlands of the island Floreana
migrating feral cattle and donkeys have formed
ravines into the tuff rock. At the west-coast of
the island Floreana El Niño-events caused severe
soil erosion for the first time in Holocene
after the vegetation cover was degraded by land
use in the 20th century. The water balance of
the crater lake El Junco on the island San
Christóbal changed after humans and domestic
animals destroyed the unique primary vegetation.
top
Soils and Societies
Hans-Rudolf Bork & Andreas Mieth
Soils
are changing their properties permanently due to
internal processes short term and long term
climate fluctuations and changes human
activities. Soils as key elements of ecosystems
are affected intensively by land use since the
rise of agriculture. The long term quantitative
consequences of human activities on the
development and the destruction of soils are
widely unknown. The complex long term soil
formation – soil erosion – climate – land use –
landscape structure – interactions were
investigated by the authors on several Pacific
Islands, in China, in the USA, and in Central
Europe. Economical and social changes were
common during the 20th century. Thus soil
formation processes changed and soil erosion
rates often increased dramatically and abruptly:
on Easter Island (Chile) due to intensive
sheep grazing and grassland fire since the
1930s;
on Robinson Crusoe Island (Archipelago Juan
Fernández, Chile) due to deforestation,
fire, goats, cattle, and rabbits since 1935;
on Floreana (Galápagos, Ecuador) due to
grazing since the 1950s;
in the Pacific Northwest of the USA due to
the intensification of agriculture since the
1930s;
in Central Europe during the 1950s, and
1960s due to the collectivisation or
reallocation of land and the intensification
of agriculture; and
in China during the "Great Leap Forward"
(1958-1961) due to the clearing of forest,
the introduction of new crops and new
farming practices.
The
intensive change in soil formation and the
dramatic increase in soil destruction during
20th century is thus the direct or indirect
result of colonisation, of changes in politics,
national and global economy.
top
Session 7
GIS AND COMPUTER APPLICATIONS IN ISLAND
LANDSCAPES
Thegn Ladefoged
(University of Auckland, New Zealand)
Gustaf Svedjemo
(Gotland University, Sweden)
Session Abstract
Island landscapes are dynamic entities composed
of physical and culturally defined elements.
Climatic, geographic, and geologic variables
partly constrain terrestrial and marine
resources, but social and political relations
determined availability and needs. These
contexts are not static, rather changed over
time in response to patterned and stochastic
natural processes, and the historically based
actions of people. The ability of archaeologists
to study these changing contexts is often
dependent on collecting large data sets at
multiple spatial scales ranging from the
individual artefact to island wide distributions
of features. Researchers have used a variety of
computer applications to model changing island
landscapes and the actions and responses of past
people. These include agent-based simulation
programs, GIS applications, 3-D modelling of
artifacts and features, and virtual reality
constructs. This session will explore the
theoretical and methodological issues involved
in computer based modelling of dynamic natural
and cultural processes in island landscapes.
top
Swedish Large-Scale Historical Maps as
Sources
for Archeological Research: Examples
from Gotlandic Maps from 1693-1705
Gustaf Svedjemo
Historical maps are a vital and often use source
in a variety of disciplines and applications
involving cultural resource management and
archaeology in Sweden. Since a decade or two,
they are also used in GIS-based analyses. A
large scanning project by the National Land
Survey of Sweden will make most of the hundred
of thousands of Historical maps in Sweden
available as raster images. We have analysed the
information content of a map series made over
the Island of Gotland between 1693 and 1705 and
made a database model and GIS-application for
these maps. In this article the historical maps
of Sweden is briefly presented and also some
different applications, which goes beyond the
traditional use of historical maps in GIS in
Sweden toady. These brief examples involve data
mining, statistics, retrogressive analysis and
hypothesis testing for different archaeological
research questions.
top
Landscapes of Complexity: Data Visualization and
Spatial Analysis of Prehistoric Shell Works
Sites,
Ten Thousand Islands, Florida
Margo Schwadron
The
Ten Thousand Islands are a remote archipelago of
semi-tropical mangrove islands stretching for
some 50 miles along southwest Florida's coast.
Located within this maze of islands is a complex
seascape of prehistoric shell midden mounds and
massive, human-engineered shell work sites
constructed by non-agricultural coastal
foragers. Shell work sites appear to have
similar spatial patterns, ranging from small,
simple, architecturally non-complex sites, to
massive sites containing complex, monumental
architecture. More elaborate shell works may
include features such as canals, fish ponds,
water courts, public plazas, and ceremonial or
residential mounds. Is it possible that some of
these features may have functioned to support
corporate labor activities needed to maintain an
increasing population dependent on a coastal
foraging economy? This study aims to define the
variety of shell work types and features, their
spatial patterns, and what they indicate about
site function, activities, population and social
organization. GIS, data visualization, and
spatial analysis of shell work features and site
layouts are valuable tools to enhance
interpretation of these unique island
landscapes, as well as to help build regional
settlement patterns and track social movements
over time. By comparing various island
settlement types and sizes, it is hypothesized
that variations in the spatial patterns of shell
works will reflect changes in social complexity
over time.
top
A GIS Based Model for Locating Lapita Aged
Settlements in American Samoa: Integrating
Prehistoric Landscape Change with Radiocarbon
Chronology
Alex Morrison, Tim Rieth, & David J. Addison
The
lack of Lapita pottery recovered from
archaeological deposits across the islands of
Samoa has both fascinated and perplexed
archaeologists for over 30 years. Despite
several well funded and extensive research
projects aimed at discovering early settlement
locations, only one locale (Mulifanua) has
yielded Lapita decorated pottery. Explanations
for the absence of archaeological materials
dating to this time period have often focused on
geomorphological changes associated with
tectonics and sea level. These arguments suggest
that the deposits are likely present but
extremely difficult to locate; being either
submerged under water or deeply buried beneath
colluvial runoff. Here we present a GIS model
with two main goals: First, we model the
environment of the American Samoan Islands circa
2800 B.P. We assess land availability and
environmental characteristics at this time.
Using the spatial and temporal distribution of
radiocarbon dates across the archipelago we
evaluate the results our GIS modeling. Next we
suggest a number of areas that are most likely
to contain the earliest archaeological deposits
in American Samoa. Our model has ramifications
for reviewing a number of hypotheses regarding
initial settlement of the Samoan archipelago as
well as changes in human spatial organization.
top
Pre-Historic Settlement Survey by GPS
on Contemporary Rapa Nui
Sonia Haoa, Lilian Gonzalez, & Tahira Edmunds
(CONADI)
Despite the efforts of past archaeological
surveys, there still remains thousands of
unregistered archaeological sites on Easter
Island. With funding provided from the
Corporación Nacional de Desarrollo Indígena (CONADI)
in 2005, an archaeological inventory began in
Fundo Vaitea and surrounding areas with the
objective of identifying and registering new
sites. The study area is designated to be
returned to the Rapanui people, however, before
such a process can be completed, an
archaeological study must be undertaken in order
to make recommendations concerning the
preservation and conversation of existing sites
within this area. In 2005 - 2006, more than
2,500 features were recorded using up-to-date
Global Positioning System (GPS) technology which
allowed for precise data collection. A
customized data dictionary was utlized in order
to record the specific details of each site
(i.e. individual characteristics and
measurements). This paper will discuss the data
collection methods and observations recorded
during the two year period 2005 - 2007 of the
archaeological survey.
top
Spatial Patterning and Social Complexity on Rapa
Nui (Easter Island): Assessing Settlement
and Land Use in Hanga Ho'onu
Mara Mulrooney
(University of Auckland)
Thegn Ladefoged
(University of Auckland)
Christopher Stevenson
(Virginia Department of Historic Resources,
Richmond, Virginia, USA)
The
archaeological landscape on Rapa Nui contains a
palimpsest of surface archaeological features,
reflecting a long history of settlement and land
use. The present project aims to develop a
diachronic model for changing social complexity
on the island based on the spatial and temporal
distribution of archaeological features in the
landscape. This paper presents some preliminary
results of a detailed GIS-based analysis of
surface archaeological features in an 8 square
kilometer
project area on the northern coast. The present
project is being carried out to examine how
different behavioural strategies that occurred
throughout the prehistoric Rapa Nui cultural
sequence are manifest in the spatial and
temporal distribution of archaeological
features. The preliminary results of spatial
analyses and seriation of over 800 features
recorded in 2006 will be presented, as well as
preliminary results of the chronometric dating
of eight residential features using obsidian
hydration dating. A model for settlement and
land use based on the preliminary findings has
been established, and this model will be revised
and tested using additional data collected
during the next two years.
top
Empirical Assessment of a Pre-European
Societal
Collapse on Rapa Nui
Thegn N. Ladefoged, Christopher Stevenson,
& Mara Mulrooney
Leading archaeologists and popular writers have
constructed narratives about pre-European
societal collapse on Rapa Nui. The island is
thought to have undergone a radical prehistoric
shift towards anarchy as the island ecosystem
was destroyed by overpopulation and
environmental catastrophe. Elements of this
story were first told by early 20th century
ethnographers. In 1955, Thor Heyerdahl's
Norwegian Expedition added to the narrative by
recovering archaeological data which they
attributed to warfare and destruction. More
recent authors have retold the account of
prehistoric societal failure, and today Rapa Nui
is often depicted as a model for world ecosystem
disaster. Despite the popularity of this
narrative, there is very little solid evidence
that drastic societal change occurred prior to
European contact. We review the evidence for
pre-European societal collapse, and consider GIS
based methodologies for establishing the dynamic
social and environmental landscape to enable the
empirical evaluation of whether or not the
narrative of Rapa Nui's prehistoric demise is
supported.
top
Computer Modeling and Visualization
of Vinapu Ceremonial Center
Paul Horley
(Yuri Fedkovych Chernivtsi National University,
Chernivtsi, Ukraine)
For
the second half of the 20th century, several
ceremonial platforms of Rapa Nui were
reconstructed, allowing the visitors to
contemplate their original majestic greatness.
At the same time, the observation confirmed more
rapid deterioration of the moai exposed
to the action of the elements in comparison with
the statues that remained partially buried
beneath the soil or rubble, which postponed
further large-scale restoration activities. One
of the possible ways to expand the number of the
sites accessible for viewing in their original
form without endangering the original monuments
is to use computers to re-create their
three-dimensional models from the actual
measurements, maps and photos. In this paper, a
three-dimensional model of the ceremonial center
of Vinapu was constructed basing on the maps and
photos published by Dr. William Mulloy in the
Reports of the Norwegian Archaeological
Expedition to Easter Island, 1955-56. Fine model
geometry adjustment and texturization were
performed using the photos taken by the author
at the site in 2002. In the framework of the
hypothesis that the proportions of the moai
obey the golden section rule, the toppled
statues were tentatively modeled after the set
of their measurements available in the
literature, which allowed us to make the
conjectural reconstruction of the site following
the drawings of William Mulloy. Obtained model
of the site was used to perform the calculations
concerning its visibility ranges from both land
and sea, confirming that Yuri Lisyanskiy and
other early visitors could have seen the main
platform with the standing statues quite well
without the aid of any telescopic equipment, if
they were within 3 kilometers from the shore.
top
GIS and Computer Applications in Easter Island
Patricia Vargas, Claudio Cristino, & Roberto
Izaurieta
(Department of Anthropology and
Easter Island
Studies Institute, University of Chile)
This
paper presents the implementation and use of GIS
and Computer applications in Easter Island with
several examples of the remarkable analytical
capacity of these tools in the interpretation of
archaeological survey data within the isle
landscape. It further reviews the variables and
methodology involved in the geodesic
transformations required for the adjustment of
the Easter Island Archaeological Survey's
cartography — originally in Datum Easter Island,
1967 — into the current world geodetic system
WGS84, base of the NAVSTAR GPS system, and
explore the archaeological fieldwork limitations
and problems of the absolute method used by the
"satellite navigators" in relation with the
cartographic scales considered.
top
Five Minute Presentation on: Searchable Online
Bibliographic Database of Pacific Archaeology
David Addison
We
describe the current status of a project
creating a searchable online database of
references for Pacific archaeology. The project
will in the future aim to provide full-text of
early or hard to find references.
top
Session 8
SEASCAPES AND ISLAND ARCHAEOLOGY
Paul Rainbird
(University of Wales, Great Britain)
Owe Ronström
(Gotland University, Sweden)
Session Abstract
It
has for long been accepted that landscapes are
polyvocal and in this meaningful to different
people in different ways. Anthropologists and
archaeologists have attempted to tease out these
multiple meanings and in doing so have given us
nuanced understandings of landscape perceptions
which have enhanced the knowledge of histories
and geographies of various places. It can be
argued that seascapes are equally ingrained with
multiple understandings beyond a simple
perception of "bridge or barrier". This session
invites contributions which considers the
implications of the perception of the sea(s)
which is such a feature of introductory
descriptions to Easter Island (i.e., distances
to next nearest land) and also the implications
of Epeli Hau'ofa's "sea of islands" which
reverses the land / sea relation of island in a
sea so common in island archaeology.
Contributions from these perspectives which may
be regarded as enhancing our understanding of
Easter Island are welcome for any period or
place.
top
Mythicization of Tsunami in Ryukyu Islands:
A Process of Seascape Formation in Island
Societies
Akira Goto
(Nanzan University, Japan)
Concerning the origin of the Rapanui people,
"Manuscript E" says that the people started to
migrate over the sea, because of the rise of the
sea (tsunami?). It is not easy to discuss how
much tsunami has actually been the causal factor
for the migration of the Austronesians including
Rapanui people, but a very good example to
discuss the mythicization of tsunami is found in
the southernmost islands of Japan, Ryukyu
Islands. In the southwestern end of the Ryukyu
Islands, Yaeyama Region, the Great Tsunami of
the Meiwa Period (1771) caused serious damages
to the island societies. Ryukyu Islands have
been often attacked by tsunami throughout
history and a variety of tsunami legends have
been talked until today. Among these legends, a
particular type of legend is found on Ishigaki
Island that is the closest to the seismic center
of Meiwa Period Great Tsunami: men caught a
mermaid which was an incarnation of sea spirit,
and she predicted the coming of the Meiwa Period
Great Tsunami. There are many natural and
cultural features (e.g. tsunami stones) that are
said to have originated in this tsunami. Recent
geophysical studies indicate the distribution of
this type of tsunami legends well correspond to
the distribution of the damaged area of tsunami.
Thus a real tsunami event has been partly
mythicized incorporating folk beliefs. In this
presentation, I will analyze the relationship
between (1) the distribution of "tsunami
features" and the degree of damages caused by
tsunami, and (2) the type of tsunami legends and
their degree of mythicization in Ryukyu Islands.
I will then disclose the process in which
disaster of the sea is mythicized, and discuss
how natural phenomena have been culturally
conceived in the formation of seascape among the
people living in insular environments.
top
Back to the Sea: The Ahu Landscapes of
Rapa Nui
Sue Hamilton
(University College London, England)
Recent work on Rapa Nui settlement, quarrying,
resource acquisition, and ceremonial structures
has increasingly incorporated a symbolic
dimension – yet functionalist explanations of
access to land and sea resources and territory
formation still predominate. The ceremonial
platforms (ahu) of Rapa Nui, particularly
the "complex ahu" with anthropomorphic
statues (moai), have been traditionally
studied in terms of their construction elements,
their chronology, and the spatial density and
distribution of architectural types.
Lineage-based ties have been presumed between
the ahu and the land on which they are
situated. On the basis of idealised Polynesian
models of chieftain territories, these ties are
perceived as being rationalised in the spatial
clustering of ahu and their association
with hypothesized pie-shaped segments of
quotidian territorial space. In contrast, this
paper sets out to explore the spatial settings
of ahu beyond that of territory. The
landscape locales of ahu predominantly
lie physically at the interface of land and sea.
Overarching the concept of land-tied identities,
one of the most evocative characteristics of the
locations of the elaborate ahu are that
their high, dense walls which face the sea —
while the statues facing inland "turn" their
backs to the sea. The ahu are more often
than not strategically placed at good positions
to get in and out of the sea. In some cases they
incorporate aggrandized slipways, and beach
stones are components of specific elements of
their architecture. The landward locales of
ahu likewise have precise topographic
settings, and associations with natural
features. The ahu often face into
discrete valleys with view-blocking rims and
they recurrently have landscaped forecourts that
further emphasize this natural topography —
these landscaped settings often incorporate
distinctive basalt flows. The paper concludes
that when such land and sea features are
considered from a symbolic and sensory
perspective it can be suggested that the
locations of ahu are as much conceptual
as territorial.
top
Monumental Risk: Rethinking the Process
of Construction on Rapa Nui
Colin Richards
(Manchester University, England)
The
apparent self-inflicted demise of the
"classical" Rapa Nui world and its inhabitants
has over the last few years been portrayed as a
"parable" for the relentless over-exploitation
of resources in the wider world. Nowhere is this
view more powerfully mediated than through the
emotive portrayal of the Rapa Nui person cutting
down the last tree — a mindless act epitomizing
a mindless society on the brink of environmental
disaster. The appeal of this lurid
interpretation does not lie in the
archaeological and botanical evidence, but that
it resonates with our view of the externalized
and manipulative relationship between people and
the world and the conceptual framework through
which we make sense of our own experiences. Much
of this conceptual framework is captured in
Ulrich Beck's (1992) Risk Society, Towards a New
Modernity, and Anthony Giddens (1991) Modernity
and Self-identity: Self and Society in the Late
Modern Age. However, the environmental discourse
which underlies the Rapa Nui "parable" owes as
much to Mary Douglas's series of publications
beginning in 1982 with Risk and Culture: An
Essay on the Selection of Technological and
Environmental Dangers (with A. Wildavsky).
Although there exist many interesting issues to
be explored within an examination of the concept
of "Risk Society" and the assumptions underlying
the over-exploitation debate, this paper
explores two different points from the writings
of Beck, Giddens and Douglas. The first concerns
the proposed unique understanding of risk within
high modernity which can be crudely described as
the intentional or unintentional consequence of
social action (Beck and Giddens). The second,
concerns risk as a purely social construct
(Douglas). The monumental constructions which
ensure Rapa Nui's high archaeological profile
are also held to be responsible for the
postulated "ecological disaster". Here I wish to
evaluate the nature and understanding of "risk"
within Rapa Nui monument building society. In
particular, the possibility that the concept of
risk was understood and was indeed an intrinsic
and vital component of monumental construction
within the discourse of social competition.
Through an examination of construction as a
social process, from quarrying to transportation
to ahu construction, it will be argued
that Rapa Nui society could be described as a
"Risk Society" and that the technologies of
construction permeated every aspect of peoples
lives.
top
Session 9
TRANS-PACIFIC CONTACTS:
NEW WINE FOR AN OLD BOTTLE
Jose Miguel Ramirez Aliaga
(Universidad de Valparaiso, Chile)
Session Abstract
Prehistoric movements across oceans should be
viewed as not only feasible but faster than
crossing continents. By sailing eastward,
Polynesians discovered tiny Rapa Nui and might
they have continued on to central or southern
Chile. We also put forth the hypothesis that
South American Indian groups made exploratory
ventures into the Pacific region. It is widely
accepted that the sweet potato was introduced
into the Polynesian culture area, however, a
more thorough analysis of cultural traits is
needed to determine which Polynesian cultural
institutions originated from from contact with
indigenous American Indian groups.
top
Linguistic Evidence for Polynesian-American
Contact
Kathryn A. Klar
(University of California, Berkeley)
A
small but steadily increasing number of
carefully-scrutinized lexical items suggests the
occurrence of at least a few prehistoric contact
events between Polynesian mariners and Native
peoples of the west coasts of North and South
America. In North America, the Southern
California Chumashan *tomolo'o "sewn-plank
canoe" and the Gabrielino ti'at "sewn-plank
canoe" and tarayna "boat" are best understood as
being derived by borrowing from Central Eastern
Polynesian sailing vocabulary. In Polynesia,
kumara (and variants) 'sweet potato' is believed
to have been borrowed from a coastal South
American language, and toki "basalt adze" may
have been borrowed from Polynesia into South
America. In this paper, I present two additional
forms which support the contact hypothesis. From
the Kawesqar (Alacaluf) group, who built
sewn-plank canoes, Captain Robert Fitzroy (of
Beagle fame) collected a form kialu "West
Patagonian canoe"; this could plausibly derive
from a Polynesian form ancestral to the modern
Hawaiian compound kialoa "long, swift, light
canoe". In addition, a possible shared word for
"harpoon" or "spear" or "ironwood" (the material
from which the weapons were made) exists in Chumashan w l
"harpoon; ironwood"; Alacaluf
(collected by Hyades) ou-léé "spear, harpoon";
and Hawaiian welau, elau, "spear point; tip,
top, extremity" (Pukui and Elbert); Maori tavero
"lance longue" (Jaussen) and Tuamotuan vero "to
throw / hurl a spear / dart" (Stimson. Taken
together with the archaeological evidence, these
forms offer compelling support for prehistoric
Polynesian-American contact.
top
Polynesians in the New World:
The Chumash Connection and Beyond
Terry L. Jones
(California Polytechnic State University)
Similarities in material culture, including sewn
plank boat construction, compound bone
fishhooks, and carved wooden bowls, compliment
linguistic findings indicating at least one
contact event between the Chumash and Gabrielino
of southern California and Polynesian voyageurs.
Oral traditions from Hawaii include an account
of a voyage to America, while stories associated
with the invention of sewn plank canoes among
the Chumash allude to an intrusion from
outsiders. Earlier estimates for the timing of
this event between ca. cal A.D. 400 and 800
based on insecure proxy evidence are revised to
cal A.D. 600-800 for a voyage that originated in
Hawaii, although the possibility of an eastern
Polynesian starting point cannot be ruled out.
Strong similarities in the material culture of
southern South America and the southern
California coast, including compound bone
fishhooks, barbed harpoons, and sewn plank boats
compliment new linguistic findings that suggest
yet another Polynesia-New World nexus.
top
Origins and Affinities of Pre-Columbian
South American Chickens
Alice A. Storey
(University of Auckland)
Debates about the date of introduction and
ultimate origins of chickens in South America
have raged for decades. Through the application
of radiocarbon dating and PCR amplification of
ancient DNA sequences these debates can now be
resolved. Recent evidence now suggests
Polynesians introduced chickens to South America
at least a century before Columbus arrived on
the East Coast. The mtDNA evidence for this
introduction of chickens, as well as subsequent
introductions both in the pre-Columbian and
historic periods will be discussed and future
research directions explored.
top
The Polynesia - Mapuche Transpacific Contact
Jose Miguel Ramirez-Aliaga
(Universidad de Valparaiso)
A
number of cultural parallels between Polynesia
and South America have been explained as
borrowings from one side or the other, but there
was no way to prove they were independent
developments either. Recently, the first
evidence for a Polynesian contact was found in
central-south Chile, the land of the pre-Hispanic and present Mapuche people (Lat. 32º
to 42º South). A number of Polynesian like
traits have been described among the Mapuche:
hand clubs similar to the Maori wahaika, axes
called toki and axe-like pendants called
toki
kura, besides other linguistics matchings. Some
cultural parallels could remain as independent
inventions, like the cooking oven or some
fishing techniques, while others can be
borrowings from Quechua, like the potato called
"kumaka" in Chiloe island, but the first strong
evidence for a direct Polynesian contact with a
South American pre-Hispanic culture contact makes
the Mapuche a new member of the old Pacific
world. A new approach to the Maori - Mapuche
materials is provided.
top
Session 10
STATE OF THE ART: THEORY, INTERPRETATION,
AND SYMBOLISM OF OCEANIC ROCK ART
Sidsel Millerström
(University of California at Berkeley)
Edmundo Edwards
(Rapa Nui)
Session Abstract
Within academia, the study of rock art, or
images on rocks, has been traditionally treated
as a "poor cousin", particularly in the United
States. This was mainly because images painted
or carved on rocks were not considered datable,
they were not thought of as a force in culture
change, and many studies lacked archaeological
context. However, in the last few decades,
large-scale field projects, some within the
context of settlement landscape studies, have
taken place on all the major Pacific islands.
Thus we now know considerably more about this
part of the Oceanic cultural past. In this
session we invite contributors to present their
projects, methods, and theories that have led to
interpretation and the understanding of
symbolism within the Oceanic milieu.
top
East-Borneo: A New Cornerstone in NW
Indo-Pacific Rock Art?
Jean-Michel Chazine
(CNRS, Maison Asie-Pacifique,
Université de Provence, Marseille)
Archaeological surveys and researches conducted
in East Kalimantan province (Indonesian Borneo)
since 1992, have begun to unveil a large number
of occupation remains. Although the oldest
Pleistocene levels have not yet been reached,
attested clues dated from late Pleistocene
(12.000 y. B.P.) to late Holocene (500-200 y.
B.P.) are largely present. Within these remains
a particular and totally unexpected rock art
expression has been discovered. Although some
rock art had already been observed in Northern
Borneo and the neighbouring Nusantaraan islands
(Sulawesi, Moluccas, Timor or Irian Jaya) it had
been attributed either to some Australian
Aboriginal late influence, either to
Austronesian influence. The oldest expressions
we have yet studied being dated at least from
late Pleistocene period (more than 10,000 y. B.P.),
that rock art would anyway predate any
Austronesian influence. That latter being
visibly attested by the occurrence of ceramic,
some 4,000 to 3,500 years ago. Borneo's rock art
present different specificities including a
relatively large number of negative hand prints
(more than 1,800 within some 35 ornate caves
already studied). These latter themselves being
often over impressed and / or linked together,
forming groups or clusters whose function
although still puzzling, may suggest some
therapeutic / initiatic activities (it includes
the gender decipheration of hand prints showing
the presence of women in painting activities).
More recent complementary discoveries (decorated
funerary jars, burials and / or ochre-coated bones
for instance), present such strange formal
similarities with the "Lapita cultural complex"
that questions and hypothesis concerning its
extension area and process may be suggested.
top
Melanesian Petroglyphs: A Proposal
of Typology
for New Caledonia
Christoph Sand & Jean Monnin
(Departement Archeologie, Service des Musees
et du Patrimoine de Nouvelle-Caledonie)
Even
if the presence of pre-colonial rock art has
been identified early in Island Melanesia by
European visitors, few focussed studies have
been attempted to date on this topic in the
western Pacific, compared to Eastern Polynesia
and New Zealand. New Caledonia, located at the
southern tip of the Melanesian croissant, has
since long been recognized as one of the
archipelagos of Oceania where this tradition
flourished during prehistory. The survey of
several hundred petroglyph sites by J. Monnin,
mainly on the Main Island, has allowed to record
over 3,000 different engravings. After a general
presentation of the background about the petroglyphs of New Caledonia, we present in this
paper a proposal of expanded typology, divided
into 40 categories, taking into account internal
variations. These will be compared to a regional
set of designs to highlight the existence of a
related set of "Melanesian" motifs in Oceania.
top
A Second Look at Cupules in Polynesia: Process
or Symbol?
Georgia Lee, Ph.D
(Easter Island Foundation)
Small
man-made pits on stone surfaces are found all
over the world and are the earliest known human
markings. This paper discusses cupules found on
Rapa Nui and compares them with the thousands of
similar petroglyphs from the Big Island of
Hawai'i. Were they part of a process, or
functional? What did they symbolize?
top
Na Kamaho'oki'ipohakukai
–
The Maritime Rock Artists of Hawai'i.
Richard W. Rogers
(Hawai'i)
Rock-artwork, often referred to as petroglyphs,
are well known and documented in the Hawaiian
Islands, particularly on the "Big Island" of
Hawai'i. Amongst the thousands of images carved
into rock are a numbers of images that show
western influence on the Hawaiian culture. These
would include Hawaiian words using the English
style alphabet, zoo-morphs, including goats and
horses as well as themes such as fire-arms and
sailing vessels. It is this last category that
this paper will deal with in some depth. There
are some fifty images carved into rock amongst
the Hawaiian Islands that clearly depict sailing
vessels of a western design. This paper will
look at the known rock images of such vessels
beginning with the easternmost and moving across
the state of Hawaii towards the west. We will be
looking not only at the type of vessel
portrayed, but consider the location and
orientation of the ship-petroglyphs. We will
also view some of the details of these images
and contemplate what the artist was trying to
portray.
top
Archaeological Art at Kahikinui and Nu'u, Maui,
Hawaiian Islands: Rock Images within two
Polynesian Settlement Landscapes
Sidsel Millerstrom
(University of California at Berkeley)
Since
1995 research on archaeological art was carried
out as a part of two major settlement-pattern
surveys at the ancient district (moku) of
Kahikinui and the land division (ahupuaha'a) of
Nu'u located on southeastern Maui Island.
Professor P.V. Kirch led these projects with
teams from University of California, Berkeley.
At Kahikinui 17 petroglyphs and pictograph
sites, containing a total of 168 glyphic units
were documented and analyzed. At Nu'u we
documented 604 individual petroglyphs at 5
sites. Images both at Kahikinui and Nu'u vary in
the number of images, site context, spatial
distribution, and especially geological
conditions. Thus these two diverse landscapes
provide a unique opportunity to examine if
geological conditions are reflected in the rock
art or if other forces are at play.
top
Session 11
PACIFIC OSTEOLOGY AND ANCIENT DNA
Frederique Valentin
(Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique,
France)
Session Abstract
Bones
and teeth are a direct witness of living humans
as well as animals that documents both
population movements and lifestyles. The purpose
of this session is to explore current evidence
related to colonisation history and subsequent
developments in Pacific islands. Papers based on
osteological and ancient DNA studies of humans
and domesticated and commensal animals are
solicited to discuss these themes and help to
clarify Polynesian islands settlement.
top
Pigs, People, and the Pacific: New Evidence for
Neolithic Dispersal in Island Southeast Asia and
Oceania
K. Dobney
(University of Durham, UK)
G. Larson
(Uppsala University Biomedical Center, Sweden)
T. Cucchi
(University of Durham, UK)
Throughout human history, animals have played a
key and often intrinsic part in both human
dispersal and trade and exchange networks, with
some of the earliest known translocations of
animals by people occurring in Island Melanesia
during the late Pleistocene. The advent of
farming during the Neolithic involved
domesticated plants and animals accompanying
humans in perhaps one of the greatest diaspora
ever undertaken by any species across the globe.
Traditionally, linguistic, genetic and
archaeological evidence have been used to
construct dispersal models of the Neolithic
cultural package from mainland East Asia,
through Island South East Asia, into Wallacea,
Island Melanesia and finally into Near and
Remote Oceania. In this paper, through the
techniques of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) and
geometric morphometric analysis of molar teeth,
we present evidence of a number of
human-mediated dispersals of pig (Sus
sp.) within Island South East Asia (ISEA) into
Oceania. One is unequivocally associated with
the Neolithic (Lapita) and later Polynesian
migrations, and links modern and archaeological
Javan, Sumatran, Wallacean, Island Melanesian
and Oceanic pigs with mainland S.E. Asian Sus
scrofa. Another links mainland East Asian
pigs to western Micronesia, Taiwan and the
Philippines. A final one supports an early
human-mediated translocation of the endemic
Sulawesi warty pig (Sus celebensis) to
Flores and Timor. These results provide
important new data with which to test and refine
current models for human dispersal in the
region.
top
What Can Ancient DNA Tell Us About Lapita and
Post-Lapita Origins and Interactions?
E. Matisoo-Smith, J. Robins, A. Storey,
M. Hingston, & M. Pierson
(University of Auckland and Allan Wilson Centre
for Molecular Ecology and Evolution)
Does
aDNA provide answers or just create new
questions? This paper will review the last 10
years of ancient DNA research in the Pacific
focusing both on commensal animals (rats, dogs,
pigs, and chickens) and recent human data. We
will discuss the most up-to-date results and the
resulting questions the data have highlighted.
Specifically we will discuss issues such as
multiple population origins, evidence of
interaction and mobility and future applications
for aDNA research in the Pacific.
top
Lapita-Associated Skeletons in the South Pacific
K. Katayama
(Graduate School of Science, Kyoto University,
Japan)
P. Nunn
(Dept. of Geography, University of South
Pacific, Fiji)
R. Kumar
(Dept. of Geography, University of South
Pacific, Fiji)
H. Oda
(Center for Chronology Study, Nagoya University,
Japan)
M. Minagawa
(Dept. of Earth Sciences, Hokkaido University,
Japan)
A
Lapita-associated human skeleton was discovered
from the Naitabale site on the Moturiki island,
Fiji in 2002. The burial was 150cm underground
and just under the midden which included lots of
Lapita pottery sherds. By means of the AMS
radiocarbon dating analysis of several pieces of
bone, its chronological age was estimated at
2577±26 years BP, 798 (793) 786 years BC, though
still not yet published at the moment. It was
found that at least as to the skull, the
skeleton is the best preserved among the Lapita-associated
human skeletal remains thus far found. The
skeleton was gross-anatomically analysed in
detail and processed a making-face
reconstruction in Japan before being returned to
Fiji. In the present paper, we closely describe
the skeleton named "Mana", present the results
of those analyses and briefly compare it with
the human skeletons which were excavated at
Lapita-associated sites in the South Pacific
region. Mana was found to be a female skeleton
aged at death more than some 40 years, to have
been around 160 cm tall, to be moderately
structured in the body, to be flat in the face,
and to be semi-rocker shaped on the mandible. In
conclusion we can preliminarily say that both
her facial-cranium and neuro-cranium consist of
Asiatic as well as Polynesian characters.
top
Chickens of the Sea: mtDNA and the Introduction
of Chickens to Prehistoric Oceania
Alice Storey
(University of Auckland, New Zealand)
Commensal models have revealed much about
Pacific prehistory in the past decade. The study
of the mtDNA of ancient Pacific chickens
contributes to our knowledge by allowing us to
examine multiple introductions, their origins
and relationships with Southeast Asian flocks.
Preliminary data suggests there were two
introductions of chicken to the Pacific and
these are related to geographically distinct
domestication centres in China and the Thailand /
Philippine region. Ancient DNA data for Pacific
and Southeast Asian chickens will be discussed
within current frameworks developed from
archaeology, linguistics, biological
anthropology and other commensal studies.
top
Gotlandic Hedgehogs, Where Did They Come From?
Magdalena Fraser
(Department of Archaeology and Osteology,
Gotland University, Sweden)
Anders Götherström
(Evolutionary Biology Center, Uppsala
University, Sweden)
The
question of who the first people on Gotland were
has long been debated. Lars Beckman found in his
study on classic genetic markers in the modern
population of Gotland (2000), that the people on
the eastern side of Gotland had a large
influence of Baltic genes. Unfortunately, the
study of ancient human DNA is very problematic
and to this day not a preferred way to go.
However, the aDNA study of animals might shed
some light to this question. In this study we
examine mitochondrial DNA of the control region
from hedgehogs from the east and the west coast
of Gotland that are connected with Middle
Neolithic settlements. The hedgehog seems to
have been an important animal in Scandinavia
during the Neolithic, as their bones have been
recovered as artifacts in human graves, as well
as, in the surrounding mass material, at several
locations in Sweden, Norway and Denmark. It has
been suggested that the people during the
Neolithic, brought hedgehogs with them when they
travelled either as gifts, pets, and / or food.
Gotland is an ideal locale to study migration
since it is an island in the middle of the
Baltic Sea that never has been connected to any
of the surrounding Scandinavian or European
mainland. As well as, hedgehogs cannot
physically have travelled there by themselves.
top
Cranial Evidence of Ethnicity on the Sepik
Coast,
Papua New Guinea
Michele Toomay Douglas
(University of Hawai'i, USA)
Ann L.W. Stodder
(Field Museum, Chicago, USA)
This
study reviews the several dimensions of social
and biological identity as revealed in
craniometric and nonmetric data and the patterns
of skull curation and modification in a series
of villages along the north coast and the lower
Sepik River of Papua New Guinea. Collections now
at The Field Museum of Chicago and the
Staatlichen Museum für Völkerkunde in Dresden,
Germany were acquired from this area in the late
1800s and the first decades of the 1900s, and
represent the coastal population of what was
then German New Guinea. These collections have
been used previously to represent Papua New
Guinea in macro-scale, regional investigations
of biodistance, but diversity has not been
examined at this local, micro-scale. Here we
address the question of how biological
relatedness is affected by — or reflects — the
tremendous linguistic diversity on the northern
coast of this island continent. The complete
dataset includes 40 measurements and variation
in 33 nonmetric traits assessed in 135 adult
crania, including both males and females (some
raw data provided by Michael Pietrusewsky, PhD).
The Mean Measure of Divergence statistic is
utilized to examine combined-sex non-metric
variation between the villages, while
measurements are analyzed by sex using
multivariate statistical analyses (e.g.,
discriminant function, Mahalanobis' D2) and a
clustering program. Neither Austronesian / Non-Austronesian
language divisions nor simple geographic
proximity suffice to explain the biological
patterns observed here, and we draw on
ethnographic and historical data to interpret
the relationships between particular villages.
We also discuss evidence for social identity at
individual and collective scales as revealed by
the treatment of the dead. Skulls were curated
and modified in a variety of modes, ranging from
cleaning and painting with a red wash of clay at
the western edge of the Sepik coast to the
complete over-modeling of the face by Iatmul
people on the Sepik River. The Iatmul portrait
skulls represent obvious individuation, but
study of the design motifs on skulls with
incised designs on the frontal bones reveals
both subtle individuation and the rendering of
traditional inherited designs on the skulls of
ancestors. The iconography of skull decoration
is not unique but rather the design elements are
common to a wide range of material culture in
both painted and carved media, representing the
incorporation of human remains into the realm of
things made sacred at the hand of the master
carver and painter. The designs and their
execution provide another layer of cultural data
added to the biological history already
encompassed in the cranial morphology and life
history of the individual.
top
Marquesas Islands, Intra-archipelago Cranial
Variation
Vincent H. Stefan
(Department of Anthropology, Lehman College –
CUNY,
New York, USA)
Eric Conte
(Centre de Recherche Archeologique sur la
Polynesie [CIRAP], Universite de la Polynesie
Francaise, Tahiti, Polynesie Francaise)
Pascal Sellier
(CNRS, UMR 5199 PACEA, Talence, France)
Pascal Murail
(Université Bordeaux 1, UMR 5199 PACEA, Talence,
France)
The
Marquesas Archipelago has traditionally been
divided into a northwestern and a southeastern
group. The northern group includes the islands
of Nuku Hiva, 'Ua Huka, and Ua Pou, and the
southern group includes Hiva 'Oa, Tahuata and
Fatu Hiva. The Marquesan language has been
divided into two dialects which correspond with
this archipelago division (Green, 1966), and has
been supported by the work of Lavond s & Randall
(1978) which found that the languages of the
southern islands were more closely related to
each other than either was to the northern
islands. Ethnohistoric voyaging records
indicated that there were northern and southern
interaction zones but only the occasional voyage
between. This study examines Marquesan cranial
metric traits to evaluate the level of
intra-archipelago heterogeneity and to determine
if a northern / southern division is evident cranially. The data consist of 49 cranio-facial
measurements of prehistoric Marquesans. Male and
female data were pooled for the metric data
following a Z-score standardization size
adjustment technique. The data consisted of four
island samples: Nuku Hiva (northwest) (n=103),
'Ua Huka (northwest) (n=30), Fatu Hiva
(southeast) (n=29), and a combined Hiva 'Oa / Tahuata
(southeast) (n=30). Of the 49 craniofacial
measurements, 11 are utilized in an RMET
analysis, providing unbiased D2 values of
0.083077 for Nuku Hiva-'Ua Huka, 0.068800 for
Nuku Hiva - Fatu Hiva, 0.079318 for Nuku Hiva-
Hiva 'Oa / Tahuata, 0.052701 for 'Ua Huka –Fatu
Hiva, 0.042571 for 'Ua Huka - Hiva 'Oa / Tahuata,
and 0.009082 for Fatu Hiva - Hiva 'Oa / Tahuata.
The islands of the southern group were closer to
each other than either was to the island of the
northern group. However, the crania from 'Ua Huka, a member of the northwestern group, have a
closer similarity to the islands of the
southeastern group then they do to crania from
the northwestern island of Nuku Hiva. These
results indicate that there were cranial metric
differences between the islands of the
northwestern and southeastern Marquesas Islands,
supporting the findings of previous research
that documented the linguistic and cultural
differences between those regions of the
archipelago. However, the results indicate that
'Ua Huka, an island traditionally included in
the northwestern Marquesas Islands, has an
affinity to the southeastern Marquesas Islands,
possibly due to its pivotal position as a
waypoint in the Marquesas Island interaction
sphere.
top
mtDNA Studies on Ancient and Extant Individuals
from Gambier Islands (French Polynesia):
Evidence of Melanesian Maternal Contribution
to the Settlement of Polynesia
Pascal Murail, Vincent Dubut, Marie-France
Deguilloux,
& Marie-Hél ne Pémonge
(Universite Bordeaux 1, UMR 5199 PACEA, CNRS,
Talence, France)
Sandrine Hugues
(Laboratoire de Biologie Moleculaire de la
Cellule,
UMR 5161, Lyon, France)
Lionel Chollet
(Departement de Biologie Moleculaire, Centre
Hospitalier
de Toulon-La Seyne, Toulon, France)
Eric Conte
(Centre de Recherche Archeologique sur la
Polynesie [CIRAP],
Universite de la Polynesie Francaise, Tahiti,
Polynesie Francaise)
Many
previous works have shown how genetic diversity
and phylogeography of mtDNA contribute to the
history of Polynesian settlement. They provided
several hypotheses, such as a South-East Asiatic
origin, a strong founder effect and a very weak
contribution of Melanesia to the Polynesia
peopling. Nevertheless, Polynesia is a very
large area and, up to now, some parts have yet
to be sampled. This is the case of the eastern
part of French Polynesia (South Tuamotu and
Gambier islands). We report here the results
from the analyses of mtDNA (9 bp deletion, HVS1
and HVS2 polymorphisms) from extant people from
Gambier islands and from ancient skeletons
excavated in a currently uninhabited atoll in
the Gambier islands (atoll of Temoe, 14th-17th
centuries; radiocarbon dating). After
genealogical study, we sampled 17 maternally
unrelated (at the third generation) extant
individuals, while paleogenetic studies
concerned 7 samples whose extraction and
amplification yielded aDNA sequences. We
observed that most of the mtDNA haplotypes of
the living sample's individuals belong to the
major haplogroup found in Polynesia (haplogroup
B4a1a1; Trejaut et al., 2005), except a
Melanesian haplotype (haplogroup Q1) that was
identified in 2 individuals. Similar results
were returned by the ancient DNA analyses: 6
sequences are related to the Polynesian
haplogroup B4a1a1, and one sequence is related
to the Melanesian haplogroup Q1. The occurrence
of haplogroup Q1 in the ancient sample may be an
evidence of a non negligible Melanesian
contribution to the settlement of eastern
Polynesia. The haplotype diversity observed in
both our extant and ancient Polynesian samples
also suggests a greater than expected genetic
diversity.
top
Molecular Genetic Studies of Natives on Easter
Island: Evidence of an Early Amerindian
Contribution to the Polynesian Gene Pool
Erik Thorsby
(Institute of Immunology,
Ikshospitalet-Radiumhospitalet
Medical Center and University of Oslo, Norway)
Most
archaeological and linguistic evidence suggest a
Polynesian origin of the population of Easter
Island. This view has been supported by the
identification of typical Polynesian
mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) polymorphisms in some
prehistoric skeletal remains. However, some
evidence of an early South American contact also
exist (the sweet potato, bottle gourd etc), but
earlier genetic studies have not revealed traces
of an early Amerindian contribution to the human
gene pool on the island. This was also the case
in some genetic studies we performed with
serological methods in 1971, in blood samples
collected from 69 reputedly non-admixed native
Easter Islanders. More recently, molecular DNA
typing has become possible. We therefore
analyzed DNA from 48 of the previously collected
Easter Islanders, typing them for mtDNA and Y
chromosome markers as well as high resolution
typing of the extremely polymorphic HLA genes.
All individuals carried mtDNA types and HLA
alleles previously found in Polynesia, and most
of the men carried Y chromosome markers of
Polynesian origin. A few individuals carried HLA
alleles and / or Y chromosome markers of European
origin, which probably represent traces of early
European visitors to the island (ship crew
members since Roggeveen's discovery in 1722).
More interestingly, however, some individuals
carried the HLA alleles A*0212 and B*3905, which
have several fold higher frequencies in
Amerindian populations than elsewhere in the
world and is therefore considered typical
Amerindian HLA alleles. The genealogy of some of
the individuals carrying these Amerindian HLA
alleles and their haplotypic backgrounds suggest
an introduction into Easter Island in the early
1800s or earlier; i.e., prior to the 19th century
Peruvian slave trades in Polynesia, which are
assumed to have resulted in more recent
Amerindian admixture in the area. Thus, our
studies suggest an early Amerindian contribution
to the Polynesian gene pool of Easter Island.
top
From Surf to Turf: Stable Isotope Analysis of
Changing Dietary Patterns on Aitutaki, Southern
Cook Islands
Jacqueline Craig
(University of Auckland, New Zealand)
Previous work on the large fishbone assemblages
from middens on Aitutaki, Southern Cook Islands
indicates that over time the amount of fish
consumed over-all declined, and the emphasis
shifted from deeper water fish to inner-reef
species. This pattern is seen on other islands
in the Pacific, including the Marquesas and
Rotuma, and would seem counter-intuitive for
island groups who were most likely experiencing
population growth and increased pressures on
limited land resources. Stable isotope analysis
allows us to examine this apparent shift in diet
from an entirely different angle, providing us
with a way to view the entire diet, including
plant foods, something that has not been
possible before. The two isotopes chosen for
this study, 13C and 15N, are particularly suited
to examining problems that centre around the
amounts of marine and terrestrial protein in an
individual's diet. In this case collagen from
archaeological bone was analysed, and a suite of
modern dietary sources from Aitutaki provided a
locally-specific comparison for analysis. Stable
isotope analysis also allows us to examine the
diet of the two largest Polynesian domesticates,
pigs and dogs, with an eye to using the
information to supplement the temporally uneven
human bone; a technique which has proven useful
in other parts of the world with dog bone only.
Preliminary results indicate that the fishbone
evidence is correct — over time the diet became
more focused on terrestrial foods and the amount
of fish in the diet of humans, pigs and dogs
decreased. Around the time of European contact
this trend was reversed and marine foods
increased importance. The isotope results also
suggest that the amount of offshore fish did
decrease over time and that more inshore fish
was eaten. Both pig and dog show great promise
as proxies for human bone, and changes in their
diets parallel aspects of the changes seen in
the human diet.
top
Lapita Subsistence and Health Condition:
Analysis at the Naitabale Site, Fiji
T. Ishimura
(National Research Institute for Cultural
Properties, Nara, Japan)
K. Katayama, P. Nunn, R. Kumar, S. Matararaba,
M. Minagawa,
F. Thomas, J. Davidson, & T. Worthy
This
paper discuss the subsistence and health
condition of the Lapita peoples, analyzing the
data of faunal remains and the result of stable
isotope analysis and anatomical study of human
skeletal remain ("Mana") at the Naitabale site,
Moturiki, Fiji. Faunal data suggests that the
people enjoyed marine resource from the reef in
front of the site. Data of the stable isotope
analysis suggest that Mana had a mixed
marine-terrestrial diet. These results are
consistent with the general understanding of the
Lapita subsistence. The anatomical study of Mana
reveals bad oral and dental condition, which may
reflect a disturbance of nutrition. This
evidence suggests that the Lapita peoples did
not always enjoy "natural blessing" and
sometimes suffered severe famine in a poor,
unstable, and unfamiliar environment.
top
Contributions of Dental Microwear and Stable
Isotope Analysis to Dietary Reconstruction
of Ancient Easter Islanders
C. Polet
(Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences,
Belgium)
H. Bocherens
(Universität Tübingen, Germany)
C. Bourdon
(Free University of Brussels, Belgium)
J.-F. Godart
(Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences,
Belgium)
M. Vercauteren
(Free University of Brussels, Belgium)
J.-L. Slachmuylder
(Free University of Brussels, Belgium)
Dental microwear and stable isotopes analyses
have been applied in order to bring information
on dietary habits of ancient Easter Islanders.
Both field of research have successfully been
integrated since the end of the 1970's in food
web reconstructions. The density, dimensions and
orientation of dental microwear are a function
of the type of food as well as their way of
preparation On the vestibular surface of the
teeth, the vertical and long striations would be
caused by quickly chewed meat while the short
horizontal and oblique striations would result
from the crushing of harder (more abrasive)
vegetal food. Vegetarians show also more
striations than carnivorous. Nitrogen and carbon
stable isotope signature of bone (or teeth)
collagen may be used in dietary reconstruction
because differences in isotopic composition
between various classes of foods are reflected
in the consumer tissues. Isotopic data can
distinguish between broad categories of food
(i.e. marine versus terrestrial, herbivorous
versus carnivorous). We have studied individuals
dating from the 13th to the 19th century (71 for
dental microwear and 14 for stable isotopes)
housed at the Museum Sebastian Englert (Easter
Island) and at the Royal Belgian Institute of
Natural Sciences (Belgium). Dental microwear was
examined on the vestibular surface of the first
and second molars with scanning electron
microscopy at 178 X magnification. The number of
striations, their length and their orientation
were recorded in a circular area of 300 µm
diameter using the software Microware 4.02 of P. Ungar. The isotopic analyses were carried out
from 200-300mg of bone sampled with a drill.
Collagen has been extracted by acidic
demineralization followed by a step of
contaminants removal. The isotopic compositions
were measured by mass spectrometry. Easter
Islanders display a small total number of
striations and a high proportion of horizontal
and horizontal-oblique short scratches. If one
refers to studies carried out on subjects of
known diet, these data indicate a low abrasive
vegetable food prevalence. This result can be
related to the dominance of sweet potato in
their daily meals as it is stated by historical,
ethnographical and archaeobotanical data.
Furthermore, the microwear pattern of Easter
Islanders presents the most similarities with
that of the Cistercians of the Dunes abbey of
Coxyde (Belgium, 12-15th century AD) where
marine fish consumption is attested. Stable
carbon isotopes show that marine products
represented, according to individuals, between
30 and 50% of the Easter Islanders protein
intake. Easter Islanders also display higher
nitrogen isotope ratios than other Pacific
islanders that could be explained by a higher
intake of terrestrial animal proteins. Within
our sample, we did not observe any sex or
age-related differences in microwear pattern and
stable isotopes. It indicates that these two
variables would not determine a preferential
access to the various foodstuffs. With regard to
the social status, our study shows that the
royal Miru clan can be distinguished from the
other clans on the basis of its dental microwear.
It is characterized by a lower number of
striations and less short features (0-30 µm). A
greater meat and / or fish consumption could be at
the origin of this distinction.
top
Human Diet in Prehistoric Tutuila, American
Samoa:
Carbon and Nitrogen Stable Isotope Evidence
Frederique Valentin
(UMR 7041, CNRS-Paris, France)
Estelle Herrscher
(UMR 6578, CNRS-Marseille, France)
Fiona Petchey
(Waikato Radiocarbon Dating Laboratory,
Hamilton, New Zealand)
David Addison
(Samoa Studies Institute, ASCC, American Samoa)
Stable isotope data are used in this paper to
assess human dietary patterns of prehistoric
communities from Tutuila (American Samoa)
Human
remains from three sites dated to three times
periods: 11-13th, 15-17th, and 19-20th centuries
AD, were analyzed. The earliest of these fall at
the end of what has been called the Samoa Dark
Ages, a time about which there is little
information, but which is thought to have been
formative to the later elaborated chiefdoms. The
later burials are fully within elaborated
chiefdom period. Carbon and nitrogen stable
isotopes of bone collagen provide a record of
protein consumption and the environment from
which individuals draw their resources as well
as their status along the trophic web. Stable
isotopes were measured from bone collagen of 16
human remains (4 subadults and 12 adults): 8
individuals from the Fatu-ma-Futi site, 7
individuals from the Lauli'i site and one from
the 'Ili'ili site. 13C values from Fatu-ma-Futi
display a wider variability (-19.4 to -17.2 ‰ [
= 2.2 ‰]) than individuals from Lauli'i (-18.4
to 17.7 ‰ [ = 0.7 ‰]). Such a difference may
suggest that the Fatu-ma-Futi individuals relied
on more diversified resources. 15N values are
much higher in the Lauli'i individuals (10.4 to
16.5 ‰) compared with the Fatu-ma-Futi
individuals (9.1 to 14.3 ‰). A higher
consumption of animal proteins at Lauli'i could
explain these results. The adult from 'Ili'ili
has 13C value of -17.3 ‰ and 15N of -10.5 ‰.
There is no significant statistical difference
in 15N and 13C values between sites (U-Test of
Mann-Whitney, p > 0.05), but 13C values are
significantly different (U-Test of Mann-Whitney,
U = 2.5, p = 0.006) when the more represented
chronological periods are compared. The present
evidence suggests that the earlier individuals
dated to the 11-13th century AD consumed more
marine resources or C4 plants compared with
individuals who lived around 450-350 years ago.
It is also interesting to note that the
individual from 'Ili'ili — dated provisionally
to 1815-1933 cal AD — shows the highest d13C
value suggesting a either a higher consumption
of C4 plants or marine food. To conclude,
isotopic evidence indicates that these
communities probably consumed a mixed diet based
on terrestrial and marine food, and there was
with a transition from a higher dependence on
marine items to a more terrestrial diet over
time. Several possibilities are suggested by the
results and these include: changes in community
specialization; marine resource depression; disintensification of marine procurement;
intensification of horticultural production; and
cultural or social changes in resource
allocation.
top
Session 12
EASTER ISLAND HUMAN OSTEOLOGY
George Gill
(University of Wyoming).
Session Abstract
The
international research team of the 1981 Easter
Island Anthropological Expedition recovered a
large number of prehistoric and protohistoric
human skeletons from several well-excavated Rapa
Nui sites. These came from both caves and ahu
from throughout the island. In the years
following the expedition's excavation, curation
and initial study came further curation and much
more osteological study involving an expansion
of the team of osteologists as well as expanded
samples of Rapa Nui skeletons from throughout
the world. Even though numerous journal
articles, book chapters, published conference
proceedings, masters theses, and a doctoral
dissertation have all emanated from this
osteological work, a full synthesis of
osteological data from all sources (metric,
non-metric, pathology, etc.) has thus far not
been attempted. This session is a first step in
rectifying this situation. Contributions from
the human osteology team members, past and
present, have been solicited, relating to
osteometrics, discrete trait analysis,
paleopathology and cultural modifications of the
skeleton. Through these approaches a much fuller
picture is emerging of: 1) origins and
migration, 2) disease and injury, 3) tribal
endogamy and warfare, and 4) certain cultural
practices.
top
Interregional Discrete Cranial Trait Variation
Thomas A. Furgeson & George W. Gill
(University of Wyoming)
In an
initial study from 2003, regional samples of
provenienced Easter Island crania were compared
on the basis of thirty discrete cranial traits
to test for statistically significant
osteological variation between several tribal or
clan groups described in the ethnographic
record. This original study made use of discrete
cranial trait data from 106 specimens curated
and examined on Easter Island. These specimens
were divided into five groups representative of
supposed ancient Easter Island tribal or clan
regions, and preliminary intraregional tests
justified pooling males and females within
specific regions for further interregional
analyses. Interregional comparisons revealed
statistically significant variation for only two
of the thirty discrete cranial traits examined:
parietal notch bone and frontal grooves. These
differences were observed between three of the
five prehistoric tribal regions. While the
initial study suggests the possibility of some
tribal endogamy on ancient Easter Island, the
slight statistical regional variation indicates
a population far more homogeneous than
heterogeneous. The current study is an expansion
of the original study using discrete cranial
trait data from several additional specimens for
a more robust data set. These additional
specimens are provenienced Easter Island crania
from collections housed in the National Museum
of Natural History, Santiago, Chile.
top
Pelvic Variability and Sexual Dimorphism
in the Prehistoric Rapanui
Amber Harrison
(Wichita State University)
This
preliminary study investigates sexual dimorphism
and pelvic variability in the Prehistoric
Rapanui to test the efficacy of a new method of
quantifying variation using an archaeological
sample, and to test for suspected population
differences in pelvic morphology. Six pelvic
measurements were taken on a sample (n=46) of
individuals housed at the Padre Sebastian
Englert Museum in Rapa Nui, Chile. Males and
females were first evaluated using summary
statistics to determine differential size
differences, then a stepwise discriminant
function procedure was applied to determine the
reliability of the method for determining sex.
Comparisons were also made between the Rapanui
and the Terry samples of North American blacks
(n=80) and whites (n=80) to test for population
differences in size and shape. For the Rapanui,
93.3% of males were correctly classified, and
93.8% of females were correctly classified.
Comparisons indicated that there are
statistically significant size differences
between the samples. Whites were found to be
significantly larger in all dimensions, followed
by blacks, then the Rapanui. The Rapanui showed
a strikingly small, yet highly dimorphic pelvic
morphology. This investigation indicates that
the method can be used to measure sex
differences with high accuracy in the Rapanui
sample. Additionally, this research demonstrates
that population variability needs to be
considered when applying traditional methods of
sex determination using the os coxa. Future
research utilizing this isolated skeletal sample
and other geographically diverse samples may
further our understanding of pelvic variability
within and between populations and provide a new
avenue of study.
top
Skeletal Biology of the Prehistoric and
Protohistoric
Easter Island Population
George W. Gill
(University of Wyoming)
Vincent H. Stefan
(Lehman College - CUNY)
Charles M. Clow
Scott J. Baker
Since
the inception of the 1981 Easter Island
Anthropological Expedition the physical
anthropology goals of that international
project, once a sufficient, well-documented
skeletal sample was acquired, have been
basically threefold: 1) a comprehensive
description of the skeletal biology of the
prehistoric and protohistoric Rapa Nui, 2) a
phylogenetic assessment of relationships of the
ancient population as compared to other
Polynesians (and intra-island variability as
well) through both craniometric and non-metric
evaluations, and 3) a full description of
prehistoric and contact period patterns of
injury and disease as revealed through skeletal
evidence. Steady progress has been made in all
three of these areas, however, the first goal of
our project, a comprehensive skeletal biology
description, is probably the least fulfilled
objective. It is the purpose of this study to
rectify this by providing a full description of
the skeletal biology of the ancient Easter
Island people, and then to offer explanations
for patterns that have emerged from our study.
Clearly these isolated people at the most remote
southeastern corner of Polynesia exhibit some
characteristics that are quite common to other
Polynesian groups, such as medium stature,
robust skeletons, medium face form and large
crania. Other distinctive features however, such
as a dolichocranic head form and a rocker jaw
frequency of below 50% are not common in
Polynesia and require some form of explanation.
This research has resulted in a thorough
description of stature, robusticity and
craniofacial characteristics to include palate
and jaw morphology in addition to the usual
assessments of nose form, face form and vault
size and shape. We have also conducted detailed
analyses of midfacial projection, discrete trait
observations and femur morphology that produce a
biological profile on the ancient Rapa Nui that
is somewhat distinctive. Parallels in skeletal
morphology noted earlier between the prehistoric
Easter Islanders and certain paleo-American
skeletons such as Spirit Cave and Kennewick Man
have now been explored in greater depth. Our
findings have important implications with regard
to potential prehistoric migration routes,
patterns of settlement and human biological
relationships.
top
Assessing Phylogenetic Relationships
and Island Colonization: Craniometric Variation
of the Prehistoric Polynesians
Vincent H. Stefan
(Lehman College - CUNY)
The
origin, migration, evolution and interaction of
Polynesian populations as a whole, as well as
focused examination of specific islands or
archipelagos (i.e., Rapanui [Easter Islanders],
Marquesas Islands, etc.) have been the center of
Pacific investigation for many years.
Archaeological, linguistic and
genetic / serological data have played
instrumental roles towards unraveling the
answers to these questions thus far, but
physical anthropological investigations have
been contributing significantly to the
understanding of Polynesian prehistory. Over the
years the author has conducted investigations
into the origins and evolution of the Rapanui,
the intra-archipelago craniometric variation of
the Marquesas Islanders, and the biological
relationship of cranial remains of Henderson
Islanders, and during the course of these
investigations has accumulated an extensive
dataset of Polynesian craniometric data. This
study will examine the prehistoric crania of
Polynesian islands: Chatham Island; Cook
Islands, Gambier Islands; Hawai'i - O'ahu;
Marquesas Islands; New Zealand; Rapa Nui;
Society Islands - Mo'orea, Tahiti, Tuamotu
Archipelago, in an attempt to shed light on the
craniometric variation of prehistoric
Polynesians, as well as to assess their
phylogenic relationships and island colonization
history.
top
Session 13
LANGUAGE CONTACTS IN PACIFIC ISLANDS
AND THE RONGORONGO SCRIPT
OF EASTER ISLAND
Steven R. Fischer
(New Zealand)
Session Abstract
One
of the most active areas of linguistic research
in recent years is language contact — that is,
what happens to languages upon encountering
foreign tongues. The process reveals a wealth of
information about language dynamics, the
mechanics of linguistic change, social pressures
on and priorities of smaller local languages,
such as those in Pacific Islands, and their
resultant fates. The effect of French on many
East Polynesian languages, of Spanish on Rapanui,
of English on Maori, and other similar
situations provide valuable information not only
about how languages change, but why and what
this means in the larger context, particularly
for vulnerable island societies. In a similar
vein, the rongorongo script of Easter Island,
now generally accepted to be the immediate
product of such foreign contact, continues to
reveal its internal mechanism and to allow
further tentative readings.
top
Spanish in Asia, Spanish in the Pacific:
Traces, Deals and Presence
Steve Pagel
(Martin-Luther-University Halle-Wittenberg,
Germany)
Spanish language has played or continues to play
a major role in three particular regions in the
Asian-Pacific area: the Marianas, the
Philippines and Rapa Nui (Easter Island). While
the Marianas and the Philippines ceased to be a
Spanish colony in 1898, Chile only began to rule
over Rapa Nui — or Isla de Pascua — in 1888, and
continues to do so today. The central aim of
this presentation is a confrontation of the
linguistic heritage of Spanish in these three
regions, which can be described as both diverse
and alike. In all three cases, one or more
autochthonous languages has been or is being
influenced by Spanish — to a varying degree, but
along similar paths of contact-induced change.
In all three cases, one or more local variety(ies)
of Spanish existed or continue to exist,
differing to a large extend from both European
and Latin-American Spanish. Along the lines of a
corpus-based analysis, we will argue that
linguistic contact with Spanish in the
Asian-Pacific area can be grasped in the shape
of at least three different stages, portrayed
here as traces, deals and presence.
top
Language Contact in the Reefislands:
Keeping
One's Distance at Close Quarters
Åshild Naess
(University of Oslo)
Even Hovdhaugen
(University of Oslo)
The
Reefislands, in the easternmost part of the
Solomon Islands, is an area of long-standing
language contact. The Polynesian Outlier
Vaeakau-Taumako (also known as Pileni) is spoken
by some 500 people in the smallest and most
marginal of the islands, while in the Main Reefs
the unclassified Äiwoo (Reefs) language has
about 5-6,000 speakers. The two language
communities are geographically very close
together, and trade and intermarriage across the
linguistic border have been common probably for
centuries. Some interesting observations can be
made concerning the effects of this contact
situation. Firstly, Äiwoo shows a large number
of VAT loanwords; on the other hand, we have not
been able to identify more than a dozen or so
obvious Äiwoo loanwords in VAT. In other words,
borrowing appears to be much more common from
the smaller, more marginal language into the
larger, more dominant one, a sociolinguistically
unusual situation. At the same time, the two
languages share a number of quite complex and
unusual structural properties, some of which may
have spread from Äiwoo to VAT, or developed in
parallel in both languages. A tentative
explanation for this situation is that the VAT
speakers attempt to protect their linguistic
identity by avoiding as far as possible obvious
lexical borrowings from their larger and
economically more powerful neighbours. On the
other hand, the levels of morphosyntax and
discourse structure are less readily available
to conscious manipulation, and so may be more
susceptible to influence through contact.
Interestingly, VAT shows a number of innovations
in the direction of greater differentiation from
Äiwoo, e.g., the realisation of a number of
consonant phonemes as [h], a sound which is
absent altogether in Äiwoo; a very large number
of articles and quantifiers, also largely absent
in Äiwoo; and the extremely frequent use of
reduplication, which exists but is fairly rare
in Äiwoo. It is tempting to analyse this
situation as a case of esoterogeny, that is,
contact-induced change motivated by the desire
to keep a language clearly distinct from that of
surrounding speech communities. Note that the
changes in question concern readily identifiable
linguistic markers such as the presence vs.
absence of [h], the presence vs. absence of
articles etc. Thus linguistic change may
function as a means of "keeping one's distance"
and maintaining a distinct linguistic identity
in a language-contact situation.
top
Hawaii Local English
Kenneth William Cook
(Hawai'i Pacific University)
In
recent years, attention has been focused on the
creole spoken in Hawaii known to residents as
"Pidgin" but called "Hawaii Creole English" by
linguists. The view taken by many-both linguists
and residents-is that in Hawaii, residents speak
either Pidgin or (North American) English, but
little attention has been paid to the fact that
the variant of English spoken by the majority of
people raised in Hawaii, i.e. Hawaii Local
English, differs from the English spoken on the
North American continent. This paper describes
this variant and contrasts it with, at times,
Pidgin but mostly with an idealized North
American English.
Example indicators of Hawaii Local English:
Phonology: palatalization of /t/ and /d/
before /r/, full vowels in unstressed syllables,
absence of offglides and syllabic nasals,
omission of postvocalic /r/, primary stress on
the second element of compound nouns, primary
stress on the /eyt/ syllable of words like
estimator, 3-1 intonation in yes-no questions
Syntax: singular verb with plural subject,
singular much with plural nouns, past perfect
for past, yeah as a tag, you folks as a pronoun
Lexicon: rubbish for garbage / trash, package for
bag, wagon for cart, certain Hawaiian words:
lanai for balcony, haole for white person, mauka
for inland; 'ohana for family, keiki for
child(ren); expressions like talk story, chicken
skin, shave ice
Names: use of full first names: Kenneth
rather than Ken; insertion of glottal stop in
names with geminate vowels: [nisi'i] for Nishii
top
Comparative Structural Analysis of Rongorongo
Script
and Rapa Nui Songs
Paul Horley
(YuriFedkovych Chernivtsi National University,
Chernivtsi, Ukraine)
Easter Island's rongoronogo script, surviving on
twenty-six wooden artifacts, has attracted
significant scientific interest since its
discovery in the second half of 19th century. In
the framework of a possible phonetic nature of
the script, statistical analysis remains one of
the most promising methods for comparative
studies of rongorongo and surviving Rapanui
lore. To perform such investigations it is
necessary to use an improved glyph
transliteration methodology that yields a
numerical corpus for the spelling variants of
rongorongo signs and matching sets of legends,
songs, etc., that may be suitable for a
comparative analysis. This paper is dedicated to
the partial solution of the aforementioned
questions. We have performed throughout a
structural analysis of the rongorongo corpus,
transliterated according to the suggested glyph
element table. The obtained transcription was
subjected to a recurrence plot analysis allowing
to extract repetitive passages and to outline
the "independent" continuous portions of the
text. Numerous passages are shared between the
inscribed artifacts, appearing in different
contexts with minor spelling variations, which
suggests they represent songs, charms or
prayers. The estimated glyph element length of
such passages correlates well with syllabic
length of short kaikai songs (published in
Campbell 1971, Blixen 1979), some of which were
said to be used as charms or spells in the past.
The sub-corpus of rongorongo passages suggestive
of the songs was extracted and subjected to a
statistical and structural analysis. The latter
confirmed the allographic nature of some
individual signs, supplied the justified basis
for the improvement of glyph element catalog and
transliteration method, and allowed to propose
the tentative reading of several glyph elements.
top
Preliminary Internal Evidence for Series of
Procreation Triads in Easter Island's Rongorongo
Corpus
Steven Roger Fischer
(Auckland, New Zealand)
For a
decade and a half it has been generally accepted
that most, but certainly not all, of Easter
Island's rongorongo texts comprise simple, fused
and / or compound logographic series of glyphic
triads conveying Agent + Patient > Issue
procreations. Such procreation triads constitute
a cosmogony, a genre well-attested in East
Polynesian oral tradition. In the rongorongo
inscriptions, reading from left to right, glyph
X (Agent, with phallus attached) copulates with
glyph Y (Patient, no phallus) and the Issue is
glyph Z. Philological evidence for this has been
external, consisting of an identical X-Y-Z
structure in a chant attested in 1886 to be an
authentic rongorongo text. Now, the rongorongo
"female marker"—three diagonal lines to the left
of an anthropomorph's head—on glyphs that are
almost exclusively in Patient (Y, no phallus)
position provides statistically significant
internal evidence for procreation triads as
well. (Rongorongo's corpus of approximately
12,000 glyphs notably absents the frequent
"female glyph" in the phallus-bearing Agent
position, with two rare exceptions.) Further
internal evidence for procreation triads lies in
pre-missionary Easter Island's only other gender
distinction: the predominantly Agent (X)
position of the moato'a "cock" glyph contrasts
conspicuously with the predominantly Patient (Y)
position of the 'uha "hen" glyph. The evidence
presented here follows rongorongo's longest and
possibly oldest inscription, that incised on the
celebrated "Santiago Staff" (RR 10).
top
Session 14
WORLD HERITAGE: INTERNATIONAL
AND PACIFIC PERSPECTIVES
Kevin Jones
(Department of Conservation Te Papa Atawhai, New
Zealand).
Anna Källén
(Stockholm University, Sweden).
Session Abstract
Heritage and World Heritage is an international
field where interests in politics, commerce,
indigenous community relations, scientific
research, representations of the past, and
creative performance are joined. The World
Heritage programme focuses international
attention on the need to maintain and restore
meaningful places that refer in one way or the
other to the past. This Stockholm University / EIF
session invites papers addressing the complexity
of the World Heritage phenomenon. We would
welcome papers discussing Heritage as an
international phenomenon, and / or with specific
examples from the Pacific. Pacific Island
nations are significantly under-represented in
the overall number of World Heritage sites,
particularly cultural sites. This conference
session should thus act as a point of focus and
shared understandings for both Pacific and
European-based scholars and indigenous Pacific
Islands people.
The session papers will be used as a point of
departure for discussions in the following
workshop World Heritage and Identity – Three
World Meet.
top
Pacific Cultural Heritage Landscapes
Kevin L. Jones
(Conservation House, New Zealand)
This
review of potential World Heritage cultural
landscapes is focussed on three themes: origins
and discovery, wetland horticulture and areas
which represent the origin of the modern
political structures of the Pacific. The World
Heritage system defines cultural landscapes to
be the "combined works of nature and man".
Landscapes can be "designed" or "organically
evolved", "continuing", or "relict". The review
is meant to explore more widely than the
tentative lists which have now been filed for
most Pacific Island countries. With the exception
of 'associative landscapes' most Pacific
cultural landscapes are organically evolved
relict ones but sometimes with strong
associative elements, e.g., Taputapuatea or
Bikini Atoll. Other landscapes identified
include Rapa Nui, Rapa, 'Opunohu valley, Mangaia,
Tumaotu Archipelago and the Line Islands
(seascapes), Mangaia, North Taranaki, Sigatoka
valley, Reef Santa Cruz Is, Tikopia, Bellona and
Rennell, and Babeldaob.
top
Managing the Meaning of Pacific World Heritage
Cate Turk
(Germany)
What
happens when Pacific cultural heritage is World
Heritage listed? As the World Heritage Committee
seek to ensure the "credibility" of the World
Heritage List, I argue the importance of not
simply reflecting on "conservation outcomes",
but examining methods of practice. In this paper
I explore what happens once a site has been
designated as World Heritage of "universal"
significance. Recounting the recent history of Tongariro National Park (New Zealand), I discuss
the consequences of World Heritage designation
and the inter-relations that constitute the
World Heritage system of government. Since
Tongariro was designated "World Heritage", the
place has become bound within an international
system of government and is at once local and
"global". I draw upon ethnographic fieldwork and
research that has tracked between the different
places where the World Heritage institution is
enacted, including the National Park, the
administrative World Heritage Centre, the
Pacific UNESCO office, and World Heritage
Committee sessions. Tongariro is a key reference
site for other potential Pacific nominations to
the World Heritage List, as it was the first
site to be listed as a "cultural landscape".
Furthermore, it is an "associative cultural
landscape" where the relationship that Maori
people, Ngati Tuwharetoa and Ngati Rangi, have
with the Tongariro landscape has been recognised
as of "outstanding universal value". I discuss
the effects of listing "cultural associations"
and examine how World Heritage management and
traditional management coincide, particularly
when tested by a controversial management
debate….
top
Global Principles for Local Practice:
New Models for the Involvement of Industry in
Heritage
Ian Lilley
(University of Queensland, Australia)
Current trends towards greater corporate social
responsibility provide opportunities for
archaeologists and heritage managers to engage
with industry and multilateral development
agencies such as the World Bank to develop
globally acceptable but locally appropriate
models of practice. Major multilateral lenders
signed up to the Equator Principles for
responsible social and environmental impact
management in development. The World Bank's
cultural heritage safeguard policy is often used
as a proxy for such principles in the heritage
field, and there are of course various UNESCO
conventions which are also applicable. All of
these covenants and policies are too abstract to
translate usefully to local situations on the
ground. What is needed is methodologically-sound
approach to translating the approaches they
advocate into procedures which also encompass
varying local realities of professional
practice.
top
Article 55 Directions: Developing and Revising
Tentative Lists and their Potential Influences –
A Quantitative Approach
Ayman Abdel Tawab
(Tanta University, Egypt)
Experts to the World Heritage Committee have
long acknowledged the significance of
undertaking serious amendments to the
Operational Guidelines to establish a
representative, balanced and credible World
Heritage List. Adopting a new section involved
with the Global Strategy, which has been one of
the key amendments carried out to the Guidelines
of 2005, represents a response to the previous
demands. Article 55, which prefaces the new
section, depends on encouraging the preparation
and submission of Tentative Lists in achieving
the objectives of the Global Strategy. The
purpose of the study was to evaluate the
potential role that the submission of Tentative
Lists might play in resolving the
representativity gaps. The study approached the
issue by means of an empirical study. Developing
and analyzing two groups of databases, involved
with the experiences of inscribing properties
and submitting Tentative Lists, was the key tool
adopted to conduct the empirical study. The
findings revealed the very limited potential
influences of submitting Tentative Lists. They
also indicated that the prosperous experiences
in submitting Tentative Lists have been
associated with the over-represented States
Parties. The results suggest re-considering the
maximum interval allowed before re-submitting
Tentative Lists.
top
Archaeological Heritage and Ecotourism: the
Hintang case
Anna Källén
(Stockholm University, Sweden)
Hintang is a group of megalithic sites in the
mountainous Hua Phan province of northeast Laos.
The French colonial archaeologist Madeleine
Colani was the first to write the extraordinary
Hintang sites into the official prehistory, and
her report has remained a rather unproblematized
source of knowledge about Hintang until our
days. In the postcolonial nation building by the
communist regime of the Lao PDR, Hintang has
been omitted from the official story of the
past, because it is not representing the past of
the dominating ethnic group Lao. Today, there is
a major development of tourism, and particularly
ecotourism, in Laos. Hintang is a target site
for ecotourism development, and Madeleine
Colani's story is now recycled and communicated
to tourists. Cultural tourism is a major income
source for most countries in Southeast Asia, and
ecotourism is an attempt to create a sustainable
and responsible tourism industry. Nevertheless
are the consequences of the ecotourists'
consumption of such unreflected archaeological
stories, for both the local community and the
tourists themselves, hardly investigated. The
paper focuses on an analysis of the production
and consumption of archaeological text in
relation to the ecotourism phenomenon,
exemplified by the Hintang case.
top
Rethinking Cultural Heritage in Southeast Asia:
A Case Study from the New Nation of Timor Leste
Sally Brockwell, Sue O'Connor, & Sandra Pannell
(Australia)
In
the forested eastern reaches of Lautem District,
the Government of Timor Leste seeks to establish
the country's first National Park – the Nino Conis Santana National Park. The proposed Park
has been identified as possessing significant
biodiversity and other natural heritage values
and outstanding cultural heritage values. The
region is also home to some 30,000 Fataluku
speakers. This paper explores ways in which the
resident Fataluku can maintain their rights to
use the land and become involved in the
management of the National Park. It examines
successful models derived from elsewhere in the
Asia-Pacific region and proposes a systematic,
traditional owner-driven investigation of
cultural heritage values and landscape use. It
aims to improve the understanding of past and
potential local use and management of natural
and cultural resources in one of the remaining
tracts of continuous lowland tropical and
monsoon forest on the island of Timor. This
proposal aligns with the priority development
areas identified by the Government of Timor
Leste, especially nature-based tourism; the role
of traditional knowledge; and community
management and use of the region's environment.
top
Session 15
WOOD SCULPTURE IN POLYNESIA
AND GENERAL SESSION
Catherine Orliac
(CNRS-Museum National d'Histoire Naturelle,
France).
Michel Orliac
(CNRS, France).
Göran Burenhult
(Gotland University)
Paul Wallin
(Gotland University)
Session Abstract
Knowledge of the exact function of certain
pieces of carved wood from ancient Polynesia
(prestige insignia, religious objects) is
sometimes revealed by ethnohistorical documents,
as is the place of various representations (zoomorphs,
anthropomorphs...) in mythology. But the
function of these artefacts also requires the
observation of the discrete traces left by their
usage. Moreover, the choice of material used —
raw material, pigments, deposits — teaches as
much about the symbolism of these materials as
about their accessibility. The study of styles,
together
with
absolute dates and the history of the
collections, enables one to define insular
identities, and establish connections. Each of
these themes could be the subject of a paper
during this session.
The general session is open for miscellaneous
papers
and late contributions.
top
Deciphering Old Catalogues:
Rediscovery of the
Rapa Nui Figures
from St. Petersburg's Kunstkamera
P. Belkov
(MAE RAS, Kunstkamera)
Until
recently the three earliest Easter Island
figures in Kunstkamera were thought to be from
the first Russian over the world voyages in 19th
century. The main document to support this
statement was the inventory of the collection
736 which is commonly considered to be
transmitted as a whole in 1828 from the Museum
of the State Admiralty Department representing
the acquisitions of Russian circumnavigators.
One of the entries of this inventory says:
"Three small idols (Easter Island)". In 1990 D. Attenborough put forward the hypothesis that
two figures were initially brought from Easter
Island to Tahiti by the second Cook expedition (regarding their
unbelievable similarity to the items in Admiral
Isaac Smith's album) and then, many years later,
in 1820 they were purchased by Captain
Bellingshausen expedition. A.L. Kaeppler
absolutely denied that these items would have
any relation to Cook's voyages. According to her
opinion, these items originated from Captain Lisyanski visit in 1804. The point is that the
inventory in question dates only 1903. Besides,
it is well known that collection number 736
running into 303 objects is nothing but a
mixture of some collections of so called
"Admiralty Museum" and Kunstkamera before 1828.
Fortunately, there is an original document which
constitutes evidence of the transmission of
items from the "Admiralty Museum" in 1828. Its
existence have never been kept a secret. This
document is named "Checklist of the Curiosities
transferred from the Museum of the former State
Admiralty Department to the Imperial Academy of
Sciences". There is no any mention about three
Rapa Nui figures in this document. On the other
hand, in the records of proceedings of the
Academy of Sciences we can find the reference to
1809: "“ØØ de Waxell envoya pour le MuseŽ
Øcademique le objets suivans quÕil a apportŽs
avec lui de Londres: É 9¡)Trois idoles des ”les
de Falkland, OtahaitŽ & SandwichÉÓ. Therefore, it seems
reasonable to conclude that three Easter Island
idols from 736 collection were given by Russian
engineer L.Waxel to the Imperial Academy of
Sciences in 1809. Practically, such a conclusion
may be equivalent to the statement about their
Cook's voyages provenance.
top
A Virgin's Birth on Easter Island: Revisiting
Maria, Madre de Rapa Nui ... Again!
Joan T. Seaver Kurze
(Easter Island Foundation)
Material for this paper was gathered on Rapa Nui
fifteen years after the island's master carvers
had produced Maria, Madre de Rapa Nui from the
trunk of a miro Tahiti (Melia azederach).
Her birth occurred during the fall of 1970, the
turbulent election year of Salvador Allende to
the presidency of Chile. At that time rumors of
divisive activities among the islanders had
upset a nervous mainland, and the Catholic
Church was asked to help. Archival reports about
the week's evangelical event in Chile's Templo
de Maipu varied considerably from those supplied
by several of the participating artisans with
whom I spoke. This episode illustrates once
again how difficult it is for citizens of the
West to communicate with people from
pre-industrialized societies. Most of the old
master carvers no longer are with us. The new
generation of Rapa Nui carvers has been exposed
to modern tools, and, by 2002, St. Michael's and
St. Francis' painted eyes had been newly
varnished along with the rest of their bodies.
Nevertheless, as long as the islanders recall
the birth of their Rapa Nui Virgin, she will
continue to spread her mana.
Botanical Identification of 198
Easter Island
Wood Carvings
Catherine Orliac
(CNRS UMR 7041 and Museum National
d'Histoire Naturelle, Paris, France)
The
botanical identification of 198 wood carvings
from Easter Island was carried out. These
objects, mainly collected during the 19th
century, are preserved in private French
collections and museums in France (Natural
History Museum of La Rochelle, Musee de l'Hospital
Maritime in Rochefort, Musee Calvet of Avignon,
the Louvre and Quay Branly museums of Paris),
England (British Museum), Belgium (Museum of Art
and History in Brussels), Germany (Museum of
Ethnography in Cologne), Switzerland (Museum of
Ethnography of Neuchatel and Barber Muller
Museum of Geneva), Italy (Congregation of Sacred
Hearts of Jesus and Mary in Rome), Norway
(Museum of Ethnography of the University of
Oslo) and Russia (Peter the Great Museum in St
Petersburg). These analyses show on the one hand
that Sophora toromiro and Thespesia populnea
were formerly used mostly by the island's
sculptors, and on the other hand that certain
types of carving (kau rongorongo, tahonga,
rapa…)
are exclusively carved in one of these two
woods. The choice of these raw materials is not
accidental; these two trees occupied a very
important place in the symbolic universe of
Easter Island.
top
Contemporary Carvers in the Marquesas Islands:
Symbolic and Stylistic Continuity and Change.
Carol S. Ivory
(Department of Fine Arts, Washington State
University, USA)
Carving remains an important activity in the
Marquesas Islands today, in part because
throughout the archipelago, the sale of carved
objects provides a significant source of income
for many families. Carved objects are produced
in a wide variety of materials, including wood,
stone, bone, and coconut. Wood remains the most
common material, especially mi'o (oceanic
rosewood, Thespesia populnea), temanu (Calophyllum
inophyllum), and tou (Cordia subcordata).
Wood carvers can be found on all of the six
inhabited Marquesan islands, but especially on
the islands of Nuku Hiva, Ua Huka, and Fatuiva.
Based on interviews conducted in October and
November 2006, this paper will focus on five or
six artists living and working on these islands.
Through their words and work, the paper will
explore the range of objects being made today.
In particular, it will discuss the distinction
the artists themselves make between
"traditional" carving (seen in objects such as
bowls, human figures tiki, war clubs, etc.) and
"creations" — objects still distinctively Marquesan in style, but in non-traditional
formats (such as tables, wall panels, etc.). It
will also discuss the factors that influence
both style and object type, especially the role
of the art market, of local carving
competitions, and the enduring impact of the
work of Karl von den Steinen and Willowdean
Handy.
top
Uses of Kite Aerial Photography in Archaeology
Elaine Dvorak
Kite
Aerial Photography (KAP) can be used to great
advantage in archaeology. KAP is a relatively
low tech application for taking aerial
photographs, which can be used to survey an
area, to describe an area to someone who is not
familiar with the exact terrain, and to assist
in locating, mapping, describing, or counting
features under study. This presentation will
show methods of using KAP, which can vary from
quite simple to very complex. On the simple end,
there is a method of using KAP with an automatic
camera that can be programmed to take pictures
at certain intervals. On the complex end, the
camera is operated by remote control and the
view from the camera can even be monitored by a
screen on the ground. With the current use of
digital photography the photographs can be taken
and viewed on a same day basis.
top
3 Dimensional Modeling on Rapa Nui
Pete Kelsey
(Autodesk, Inc., San Rafael, California)
Historically, archaeologists have used 2
Dimensional (2D) surveying and mapping
technology to inventory, map and monitor
archeological sites on Rapa Nui; this survey
technique has proved both quick and efficient as
numerous sites can be surveyed and mapped in
short periods of time. However, to effectively
monitor the erosion of the land and
deterioration of archeological sites requires
the assistance of 3 Dimensional (3D) models; the
island's topography and archaeological sites
have been impacted by natural elements, urban
development, agricultural practices, and the
growth of tourism. By utilizing Global
Positioning System (GPS) equipment and
Geographic Information System (GIS) software, 3D
models of Rapa Nui's landscape and
archaeological sites can be created and archived
allowing local experts to observe change over
time and associated impacts. 3D modeling further
provides visual clues that 2D maps cannot
produce; a 3D model of an ahu and
surrounding terrain, for example, will allow for
the examination of erosion, profiles, cross
sections, hydrology, slope and elevation
analysis. With an increasing population coupled
with the rapid growth of the tourism industry
and accelerated land development, Rapa Nui's
already fragile environment and archaeological
sites must be monitored, regulated and
controlled. Adopting 3D mapping technologies
will facilitate this, as well aid in the
protection and preservation of Rapa Nui's
historial landscape for future generations.
top
Re-dating Ahu Nau Nau and the Settlement
at Anakena, Rapa Nui
Paul Wallin
(Gotland University)
Helene Martinsson-Wallin
(Gotland University)
Göran Possnert
(Uppsala University)
The
construction and early use phase of Ahu Nau Nau
have been re-dated by nine charcoal and rat bone
samples. The new datings in comparison with
earlier data suggests that the ahu was
constructed around 650-550 BP. It is also
suggested that a settlement dated to c. 950-900
BP preceded the ahu building phase. A new
question in the light of recent research might
be raised: Is the earliest settlement on Rapa
Nui found at Anakena or should we look somewhere
else?
top
Workshop
"World Heritage
and Identity:
Three Worlds Meet"
Olaug Andreassen
University of New South Wales, Sydney, Australia
Anna Karlström
Uppsala University, Sweden
Gunilla Hallin
Gotland University, Sweden
top
General Session
Göran Burenhult
Gotland University, Sweden
Paul Wallin
Gotland University, Sweden
top
Poster Session
Ilse Vuijsters
Gotland University, Sweden
Joakim Wehlin
Gotland University, Sweden
top